The leases on Pittsburgh’s North Shore stadiums are coming up for renewal in 2030, which means it’s time to start thinking about the economic costs and benefits of the city’s major sports teams. At PNC Park, the $260 million price tag for the facility was shouldered largely by taxpayers — but this huge public investment isn’t being reciprocated by ownership.
With such a huge public investment met with a pittance in private spending, the public has a right to demand more — and to hold out for more before signing another generation-long lease on a public facility.
The Pirates have had only four winning seasons in the last 30 years, and payroll has consistently ranked among the bottom five across all of Major League Baseball. No team has spent less on free agency signings in the last three decades. Currently, the Pirates have a payroll of $75.6 million, 28th out of the 30 MLB teams. Post-Gazette columnist Paul Zeise recently compared this to three similar markets: Kansas City and Cincinnati both spend roughly $96 million, and Milwaukee $125 million.
Yet the franchise continues to be profitable, because in spite of it all Pittsburghers love their Pirates, and buy tickets and branded gear. Owner Bob Nutting’s refusal to invest more money into the team has show no signs of relenting leading up to the end of the team’s ballpark lease.
We applaud state representatives Tim Bonner, R-Mercer/Butler, and Jim Gregory, R-Blair, for turning up the heat. They recently commissioned a study by the Independent Fiscal Office to quantify the economic impact of even a modestly more-successful team. The study’s conclusion: just three more wins each season would increase fan spending by $76 million.
Now, that’s a hefty sum based on some lofty assumptions. But regardless of the precise numbers, there’s a clear relationship between the Pirates’ success and attendance at PNC Park, and all the economic benefits, such as spending at hotels and restaurants, that go with it. There is a major public interest in the Pirates being competitive.
A generation ago, PNC Park was built using $75 million in state grant funding, while Allegheny County taxpayers added another $147 million. The Pirates contributed a paltry $40 million, and their penny-pinching has continued ever since.
The stadium is owned by the Sports and Exhibition Authority of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, which makes decisions about the park’s tenants. Having one of the most beautiful and best-regarded ballparks in the world is a major bargaining chip public officials should use to the fullest effect. Mr. Nutting should be made to earn his lease by contributing fairly to the success of the team and its city.
We fully expect that Mr. Nutting will make noises in the coming years about moving the franchise elsewhere, such as Nashville, if he doesn’t receive favorable terms. To which we say: good riddance. Pittsburgh will still have the best ballpark, ready for a great baseball team. Someone else will get the junk.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.