The reopening of Shuman Juvenile Detention Center ran into hiccups this week when operator Adelphoi set a reopening date of last Tuesday, then journalists visited and discovered ongoing construction and a seemingly insecure entrance. Despite this awkward incident, there’s every reason to believe that Shuman, under the guidance of an invested County Executive Sara Innamorato and President Judge Susan Evashavik DiLucente, will be able to fulfill its rehabilitative mission.
There is no single perfect solution for minors who require the intervention of the criminal justice system — but having a dedicated detention facility within the county is essential to ensure a full suite of options, tailored to each case.
The process of reopening Shuman — now called Highland Detention at Shuman Center — has been mired in controversy and ongoing litigation over the County Executive’s authority to contract out its operation to a private agency. While we would prefer the county run the center itself, it has proven unable and unwilling to do so with the level of professionalism required. Bringing in an outside agency is an acceptable second option — and time was of the essence.
Adelphoi, the Latrobe-based social services organization contracted to run Shuman, is not perfect, as evidenced by lawsuits alleging abuse at its Westmoreland County facilities. The agency works with some of the most difficult cases in all of social services, and will require close oversight from the county.
Ms. Innamorato, for her part, has decisively shifted the focus of her administration to social and criminal justice issues. She attends Jail Oversight Board meetings regularly and recently revived the Shuman Advisory Board. That board is anchored by Judges Tiffany E. Sizemore and Jennifer Staley McCrady, both legal professionals with career-long investment in juvenile criminal justice.
As these judges know, reopening Shuman is an unfortunate necessity. Minors with criminal charges have few options in Allegheny County: They may be booked into Allegheny County Jail among adult offenders, sent to facilities outside the county and away from critical support systems, or be released on electronic monitoring.
Allegheny County Jail, which currently has zero therapists, critical openings in medical staff and so few correctional officers that the facility regularly goes into lockdown, is a deeply damaging place for children. On the other hand, sending minors outside the county places a huge burden on family members trying to communicate with children and coordinate legal representation.
Meanwhile, electronic monitoring has neither helped young people nor protected the public. Last February, a 14-year-old boy released on house arrest left his home and killed a 17-year-old acquaintance. All it took was 14 minutes. From 2022 to early 2024, juvenile offenders either cut off ankle monitors or let the batteries die some 436 times.
Such incidents demonstrate the inadequacy of options for juvenile offenders in Allegheny County. Adelphoi estimates that, from December 2021 and October 2023, 234 young offenders would have been eligible for the facility. It’s high time to make that option available again.
If Ms. Innamorato and her appointees remain vigilant — and we have every reason to believe they will — reopening Shuman fully may be a positive turning point in Allegheny County’s approach to juvenile justice.
Clarification: This editorial has been updated to reflect that Shuman was open and operating on Tuesday, July 2, despite visible construction at the site.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.