While the ongoing staffing crisis at the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police has generated numerous headlines, another branch of the city’s public safety apparatus has quietly been struggling: the Bureau of Emergency Medical Services.
Pittsburgh EMS is operating at its lowest manpower levels in decades. This has resulted in EMS Chief Amera Gilchrist taking the unprecedented step of taking one of the city’s 13 medic units out of service.
Meanwhile, just like with the police, the necessity of forced overtime is contributing to low morale that is further undercutting the bureau’s ability to staff up. New information shows that for special events, like concerts and sports, venues are paying more money than ever to suburban EMS agencies to fulfill responsibilities the city cannot.
The Gainey administration has made progress in key respects, including creating a new EMT training program and working to streamline the bureau’s hiring process. However, the lack of a contract for the EMS union is a sore spot, and it’s likely that more robust reforms will be necessary. Two areas where Pittsburgh is an outlier among peer cities should be on the table: Eliminating residency requirements, and merging the EMS and Fire bureaus.
Struggling bureau
Pittsburgh’s 2024 budget includes funding for 172 paramedics and 28 emergency medical technicians (EMTs), who require significantly less training and respond to less serious calls. But right now there are only 142 paramedics and 15 EMTs on staff. That means that, as a percentage of budgeted figures, the EMS Bureau is even more short-staffed than the police.
As a concession to this reality, Ms. Gilchrist has shut down Medic 11, which is based at the Homewood EMS station and covers parts of Shadyside, Squirrel Hill, Point Breeze, Homewood and East Hills, on a month-to-month basis. Calls in that area are distributed among other nearby medic units. No medic unit had ever previously been taken off-line in a long-term way.
Another symptom of the EMS staffing crisis has been unprecedented payments to suburban ambulance services to cover events in the city. Already this year, over $100,000 has passed through the city’s Special Events Fund from event venues and organizers to agencies as far away as Vandergrift and Ford City. Last year it was over $300,000, about three times more than the pre-COVID normal.
Some progress
The reasons for the EMS Bureau’s recruitment and retention struggles are different from the Police Bureau’s. For instance, while Pittsburgh Police base salaries — even after a lucrative new contract — compare unfavorably to the best suburban departments’, Pittsburgh paramedics get among the best pay in the region, especially when overtime is included. Emergency medicine also doesn’t face the same political and cultural headwinds as law enforcement.
One advantage the police do have, though, is their own training academy. Pittsburgh EMS depends on an outside educational pipeline, which largely consists of the University of Pittsburgh’s excellent Center for Emergency Medicine. But the program is so well-regarded that more and more of its students aren’t from Pittsburgh, and don’t intend to work as paramedics here.
Into the breach has stepped one of the Gainey administration’s true success stories: the Freedom House EMT Training Academy. The program, housed within EMS, is likely to refill the bureau’s EMT ranks very soon: Nine trainees are currently in the program. EMTs, however, can operate only in very limited capacities; this progress will not allow the bureau to bring Medic 11 back on-line.
Another issue on which Mr. Gainey’s team has made progress is the hiring process. Until recently, it took six months to go from application to the ambulance— a lengthy period during which many competent paramedics dropped out. That process, including numerous screenings and exams, is getting whittled down to 60 to 90 days.
At the same time, however, the current EMS union contract expired in December, and no new contract has been signed. This contrasts sharply with timely, lucrative new deals for the fire and police unions, suggesting the EMS union isn’t getting the attention it deserves from the Gainey administration.
Big reforms
But the biggest drag on recruitment — especially for paramedics with school-aged children — is the EMS Bureau’s city residency requirement. While the requirement, written into the city’s home rule charter, no longer applies to police and firefighters, it still does to EMS employees.
That’s because the EMS unique is unique among Public Safety unions: While the fire and police unions fall under state Act 111, which provides for binding arbitration in the event of a contract impasse, EMS falls under Act 195, which doesn’t. That means fire and police have more leverage, and courts have ruled that the city’s residency requirement can’t apply to Act 111 unions.
It’s unlikely EMS can wiggle out of the residency requirement on its own — that is, without a citywide referendum to remove the residency requirement for all city employees from the home rule charter. On this point, it’s worth observing that Pittsburgh’s residency requirement is very unusual among peer cities, such as Cleveland, Cincinnati, St. Louis and Milwaukee. The residency requirement is a legacy of a different time, and may have run its course.
But there’s another way EMS workers could gain Act 111 protections, and get out of the residency requirement: if they were folded into the Fire Bureau and its union. Once again, Pittsburgh is nearly unique among peer cities in having separate fire and EMS departments: Emergency medicine is almost always contained within fire. In Philadelphia, firefighters and paramedics are members of a joint union under Act 111.
The complications involved in such a merger would be immense, but it’s clear that Pittsburgh’s bureaucracy — despite winnowing under Act 47 state oversight — remains spendy and overbuilt. Big, difficult reforms will be necessary across the board. Preserving efficient EMS service may require those reforms to start within public safety.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.