The Commonwealth of Pennsylvania is moving forward with a full demolition of the former Western Penitentiary in accordance with a recent feasibility study. The Department of General Services, responsible for state property, picked the most expensive and hazardous option for its future — and for no clear reason.

At issue is the 142-year-old main penitentiary building: an imposing, thousand-foot-wide stone structure that runs parallel to the Ohio River in Marshall-Shadeland, where Woods Run enters the river. It is one of 40 structures currently on the property, but it is by far the largest and the only historically significant one.

A 2023 feasibility study by engineering firm Michael Baker, commissioned by the commonwealth, analyzed possible uses for the site and posited three options: Selling the property as-is to an ambitious buyer, doing a full demolition to create a brownfield development site, or demolishing the less historic parts for reuse while maintaining the historic structure.

After outlining these arguments, the study recommended the most expensive and most work-intensive option: full demolition. The DGS agreed.

Advertise with us

The process won’t be finished until 2027 and will cost $44 million. At best.

The feasibility study draws on two strange claims — to which there are simple objections — to make this recommendation.

It argues that “few, if any, buyers would be willing to assume the financial and environmental liabilities involved with preparing the site for reuse.” Two are already lined up to make their case.

One of them, Anthony Jordan, an asbestos demolition contractor with a passion for stone facades, has had huge success with a similar project. In 2017 he acquired the Trans-Allegheny Lunatic Asylum in Weston, W. Va., and renovated it into a top-five tourist attraction in the Mountain State.

The report also dismisses the site’s viability as an attraction for the film industry. It’s already been a consistent hit with production companies. At least five major productions — Mayor of Kingstown, Mindhunter, Escape from Danemora, Outsiders and American Rust — have used the site, now one of the most prominent of its kind in the country, in recent years. The closest facility that offers the same aesthetic is in Moundsville, W.Va., and destroying the penitentiary would only send more business out of the commonwealth.

Advertise with us

Some have raised concerns about maintaining a structure so visibly redolent of the injustice of mass incarceration — and this is understandable. But destroying that history isn’t the answer. Maintaining the site allows for the history — including its connection to the preceding institution, which was the first prison west of the Alleghenies and served as a Civil War prison — to be stewarded and interpreted for generations to come.

Partial demolition of the site is the best option: It could allow for the creation of a public park and a shovel-ready development site, while preserving a unique and important building that would serve as an attraction for tourists and filmmakers.

Saving parts of the prison might take more bureaucratic effort than tearing the whole thing down, but Pittsburgh, and the commonwealth, would gain by preserving rather than destroying our history.

This editorial has been updated to better reflect Western Penitentiary's connection to Civil War history.