Contrary to many reports, the Supreme Court did not criminalize homelessness last week. In City of Grants Pass v. Johnson, the court affirmed the legal reality that had already been in force in all of America until very recently: State and local governments may regulate public places to ban sleeping outdoors, including in tents or vehicles.

But just because local authorities have this power doesn’t mean they have to use it. And they shouldn’t, because the criminal justice system is not the answer for homelessness.

The legal arguments in the case examine whether outdoor sleeping restrictions criminalize the “mere status” of homelessness, which the court has previously ruled violates the Eighth Amendment prohibition on “cruel and unusual punishment.” The six more conservative justices held that these laws do not, because they apply to everyone equally — people going camping, for example — even if they primarily affect those who don’t have a place to sleep anywhere else.

The interpretation of the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, which had been binding in several Western states and applied by courts around the country, was that the law did unconstitutionally criminalize homelessness. The court held that encampment clearances are only legitimate if there is enough shelter space to make what is often called a “credible offer of housing.”

Advertise with us

This restricted many Western locales from doing anything with homeless encampments, because they could not know if the nearby shelter situation was sufficient to make and enforce regulations. California Gov. Gavin Newsom welcomed the Supreme Court’s ruling, since it removed an ambiguity that had paralyzed his state’s ability to make homelessness policy.

The official policy of the City of Pittsburgh roughly mirrors the 9th Circuit’s holding. In Pittsburgh, encampment sweeps generally involve intense coordination with social service agencies and the creation of individualized housing plans, which is laudable.

But the fact remains that some camps, especially in Downtown, have been cleared without enough indoor space to house everyone. This has resulted in the creation of a massive settlement along the Great Allegheny Passage, between the jail and the Parkway East. Under the 9th Circuit’s holding, these would likely have been subject to severe legal scrutiny and could have been ruled illegal — even if a municipality had legitimate health and safety concerns.

To be clear, neither Pittsburgh nor Allegheny County should deploy all the tools the Supreme Court has now confirmed that they have. Banning outdoor sleeping during an acute homelessness crisis does, in practice, criminalize homelessness. And it’s impractical and impossible, not to mention cruel, to arrest our way out of the problem. Both Mayor Ed Gainey and County Executive Sara Innamorato affirmed that their approaches to homelessness would not change.

But, despite the claims that the Supreme Court has ushered in dystopia, the Grants Pass decision doesn’t actually change much in Pittsburgh or elsewhere. It’s up to local officials to make sensible and compassionate homelessness policy, not the courts.