Editor’s note: After this editorial was published, Allegheny County announced that 1200 Reedsdale Street on the North Shore, not the Family Links facility in Allentown, would serve as the emergency shelter for about 100 people displaced from Second Avenue Commons. While homeless services are generally a county responsibility, we understand that city officials worked through the night to make arrangements at Reedsdale, a preferable location outside a residential neighborhood. This is a tremendous example of cooperation toward a common goal that deserves praise, and should serve as a model for other efforts, whether on homelessness or other matters.
The recent devastating fire at Second Avenue Commons, Pittsburgh’s hub for homeless services, displaced nearly 200 people and dealt a major blow to Allegheny County’s rehousing efforts. With the announcement of temporary shelter plans for most of SAC’s residents, county officials have a tremendous challenge ahead of them — but also an opportunity to reimagine homeless shelters and services in a more decentralized way.
On Friday, county Human Services chief Erin Dalton announced that a facility on Climax Street in Allentown — a former convent now run by social service provider Family Links — will serve as a temporary shelter for about 100 SAC residents. Under the circumstances, no solution will be ideal, but the Allentown choice does fulfill all the essential criteria: ready-to-use, air-conditioned (especially important with record heat on the horizon) and accessible to transit.
It must be said that community concerns about moving up to 100 displaced unhoused people into a residential neighborhood are legitimate. Many residents of the shelter will suffer from addiction or severe mental health deficits — or, at the very least, will be going through a deeply stressful period of instability in their lives. It is not easy to be forced to be hospitable to such people, especially when they will be completely new to the neighborhood.
Therefore, it will be incumbent on county officials to make the transition as humane as possible — for everyone involved. That means scheduling at least one community meeting as soon as possible and having answers for as many questions as possible; providing free bus passes so residents will be able to go about their business without simply loitering in the neighborhood; and working out a plan for a consistent professional presence — including behavioral health specialists, social workers and public safety officers — inside and outside the facility.
It is, as we have expressed about the “Second Avenue Triangle,” generally bad policy to create a nexus between homelessness and law enforcement. But in this emergency case neighborhood acceptance is critical, and a police presence will aid that.
At the same time, it is important to remember that homeless people are much more likely to be victims of violent crime than to commit violent crimes. While it is perfectly understandable for Allentown neighbors to feel that it is unfair to place this burden on them, the shelter will be more successful — and therefore safer — the more grace that is shown to the residents and staff by the community.
The Second Avenue fire has showed how fragile the county’s care system remains. Ms. Dalton said that DHS considered over 100 options before settling on Allentown. The county should keep that list handy: This could be the first step to ensuring that the concentrations of human suffering don’t perpetuate the systems — incarceration, substance abuse and so on — that lead to homelessness in the first place. Smaller shelters spread not just around the city but around the county can offer decentralized services and greater opportunities for vulnerable residents to re-enter healthy communities.
And the system wouldn’t collapse when a single emergency strikes.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.