Allegheny County and the City of Pittsburgh have funneled homeless people into a closed system of an indoor shelter, an outdoor encampment, courtrooms and the county jail — all within a triangle of about 1/10th of a square mile along the Monongahela River. This ad hoc system — this trap — represents the continuing failure of both governments to design a system of care for the unhoused that meets the standards set out by their leaders: one that results, for those who desire it, in healing and in dignified, independent living.

The Tuesday fire that rendered Second Avenue Commons — the low-barrier linchpin of the region’s homeless care system — temporarily unlivable demonstrated the insufficiency of this system.

Revolving door

Pittsburgh’s progressive leaders have said time and again that the criminal justice system cannot be the primary response to homelessness and addiction. They are absolutely correct: While law enforcement can deal with some, though not all, of the immediate challenges, the only path to a long-term solution is a continuum of care that addresses the needs of each person — mental, physical, financial.

Yet the actual situation on the ground has only further entrenched the status quo. In a triangle of land bounded by Second Avenue, the Great Allegheny Passage trail and the Liberty Bridge, the revolving door of the justice system is strikingly manifest.

Advertise with us

There is the encampment, along the trail beneath the Parkway East, where people have congregated and attempt to subsist; Second Avenue Commons, where many of those people are waiting to live, for providing something like stability; the Municipal Court Building, for arraigning the triangle’s residents on drug and other charges; and the jail, for incarcerating them — almost entirely before they’ve been convicted.

In that triangle is also an addiction treatment center called Renewal that contracts with the county court system, while just outside it, grimly, is Freedom Fast Bail Bonds. This is the extent of the world for Pittsburgh’s homeless, the world the city and county have built for them. It provides the horizons of their reality, and their hope.

Arrested development

Some experienced social service professionals warned of this outcome years ago, when Second Avenue Commons was placed nearly adjacent to the jail. But there were few options for the novel low-barrier shelter, so it’s hard to blame anyone for picking its accessible but forsaken location.

But both the city and the county have had years to ensure the area didn’t become a city-within-a-city for warehousing the unhoused, and in that they have failed.

Plans to develop “tiny house” communities with wraparound services are languishing in the Gainey administration, seemingly due to disputes over who should get credit for the project: City Council or the Mayor. Today’s announcement by the Innamorato administration, to identify 500 units of ultra-affordable housing in 500 days, is encouraging — but housing alone isn’t a panacea, because it isn’t enough for people who struggle to live independently.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, by selectively and reactively enforcing the administration’s own camp decommissioning policy, the city has nudged the unsheltered homeless down to the jail trail. The encampment is largely invisible to the public, relieving some political pressure on Mr. Gainey and Ms. Innamorato. And the triangle includes all the public “services” the people living there need.

Open season

Nearly 200 people spilled onto the sidewalk outside SAC after an air conditioning unit caused the fourth-floor conflagration. As emergency personnel and a cadre of county leadership (top city officials were noticeably absent) descended on the area, Pittsburgh firefighters pumped hundreds of thousands of gallons of water into the barely two-year-old facility. Four firefighters and two residents suffered minor injuries.

Everyone got out safely, but not everyone got out unharmed.

Before the fire trucks had even retracted their ladders, parole officers were surveying the residents forced to leave, searching for people with known violations or warrants. SAC staff members generally don’t disclose who is inside to protect the privacy and safety of their guests. But outside, they were fair game for arrest.

EBT and WIC cards, cell phones, ID cards, medications and clothing were left behind as residents fled. Pittsburgh Regional Transit buses eventually moved the 180 residents to the David L. Lawrence Convention Center — currently host to a conference of insurance professionals.

Advertise with us

This required quick thinking and organizing from county officials, who deserve praise for their efforts. But if SAC is out of commission for more than a few days, the convention center won’t suffice. The county should consider reopening the Smithfield Shelter, closed last spring, on a strictly emergency basis if SAC will take longer to come back on-line.

Freedom?

Nathan was one of the shelter’s most recent arrivals. He had few belongings following his release from the State Correctional Institution at Somerset in late April. The prison had provided him with a stockpile of important psychiatric medications before dropping him off at SAC.

The pills were now trapped in the top floor of the burned building. Instead of traveling to the Convention Center with the rest of the residents, which Nathan feared would feel too much like the institution he’d just left, he walked to the encampment underneath the Parkway. By 9 p.m. he’d moved into a tent.

The day before, when he’d received his new bedroom at SAC, he’d startled a staff member by standing up and facing the door, like he’d done every day during his time in state prison — to be counted by the guards.

“But, baby, you’re free,” she had said.

As night closed over the cluster of tents beneath the imposing facade of ACJ, nothing felt further from the truth.