While the Golden Triangle has been the primary focus of alarm due to plunging commercial property assessments in Allegheny County, suburban taxing bodies — especially school districts — are under just as much pressure. The suburbs are making a case for a reassessment — just as much as the skyscrapers currently hogging headlines.
The municipalities and districts that are seeing the biggest declines in assessed values are generally those most exposed to the commercial market. Consider the Montour School District, which includes Robinson and Kennedy townships, Ingram and Thornburg boroughs and the enclave of Pennsbury Village.
In this year alone through the end of May, overall assessed values in Montour have dropped about $100 million, or 3.4%. The current total value of $2.86 billion across the district represents a decline of $135 million, or 4.5%, from the roughly $3 billion on which the 2023-2024 budget was based.
In other words, Montour is facing a decline of nearly 5% in the source of revenue that makes up over 60% of its budget. That’s about $2.5 million — assuming no further declines, which is unlikely. But it gets worse: Because Allegheny County and its taxing bodies collect taxes before appeals are adjudicated, the value declines will trigger refunds equal to that tax loss — and possibly more, if an appeal includes more than one tax year.
This is the suburban version of the double whammy that has led Downtown skyscrapers to decline over 40% in value. A sharp decline in the common level ratio, which calculates taxable value from market value on appeal and had been artificially inflated until a 2022 court decision restored it, has combined with trouble in the commercial real estate market — particularly for offices, but also for hotels and even shopping centers — to tank commercial assessments.
For instance, the Mall at Robinson, in the Montour district, had been assessed at over $43 million for the 2021 tax year. Appeals have dropped that value to under $32 million, resulting in a tax loss of about $170,000 to the district, plus refunds.
This, in a district that has seen its reserves decline from around $13 million in 2022 to a projected $3 million at the end of the 2024-2025 school year. That’s only 4% of expenditures, while 5% is considered the minimum safe balance.
While Montour has seen an unusual dip this year, it’s far from alone. And for some communities, the biggest hits are yet to come: Hundreds of commercial appeals are still working through the Board of Property Assessment Appeals and Review.
A countywide reassessment can’t fix damage already done, and it can’t result in a tax windfall for schools or municipalities. But it can set a new, stable foundation, so appeals can’t result in wild tax revenue fluctuations.
It’s all the more reason that County Executive Sara Innamorato should be preparing for a reassessment — and should pull the trigger as soon as a court orders her to do so. Every delay will result in further erosion of the tax base for school districts across the county.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.