A move to give nearly two dozen police recruits second chances to pass the psychological evaluation demonstrates the Pittsburgh Police department’s desperation to fill its ranks. While the Post-Gazette Editorial Board has been sounding the alarm about police staffing for over 15 months now, the department can’t plug the holes with men and women unsuited to the pressures of law enforcement.
Meanwhile, news of a $315,000 state grant to enhance recruitment is welcome — but also points to the lack of seriousness with which the Gainey administration has treated the problem until now. Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt recently described recruitment before the influx of funds as “informal.”
With the ongoing loss of active officers, organized recruitment should have been a top priority for the administration from the beginning. Now officials are resorting to what Citizens Police Review Board executive director Beth Pittinger has rightly called “doctor shopping” in order to get recruits onto the force who would have been rejected in years past.
The result is a cycle that will only further damage law enforcement’s standing in the community, while making policing even less appealing as a profession for competent, compassionate men and women.
Second chances
Thirty-eight recruits were slated to begin training at the Pittsburgh Police academy on May 20. But 23 of those recruits didn’t make it through a psychological evaluation to determine their mental fitness for the job.
This raises a difficult-to-answer question: Is the problem with the evaluation (including the evaluators) or with the recruits? Gainey administration officials have hinted that it’s the former, suggesting that reforms to the psychological review process may be needed. That shouldn’t be dismissed out of hand. As we will see, the city can improve the evaluation system, especially for racial equity.
But the salient fact is this: Of the seven psychologists with whom the city contracted to perform evaluations in 2022 and 2023, six have performed these duties for the city for several years — and one as far back as 2000. Rejecting nearly two-thirds of a class is unprecedented, and strongly suggests that the quality of recruits has declined, not that experienced psychologists have arbitrarily raised or changed their standards.
Further, the process itself gives recruits multiple chances. After taking the lengthy Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory version 2 (MMPI-2), recruits sit down with a psychological evaluator. If that evaluator, armed with the MMPI results, deems the recruit unfit, he or she gets a second chance with a different evaluator. It takes two negative evaluations to eliminate a candidate: If the first two disagree, a third psychologist breaks the tie.
It’s hardly a process stacked against recruits.
Reform recommendations
One particular concern is that a disproportionate number of the candidates rejected by psychologists were Black: five Black recruits, almost the entire Black contingent, didn’t make it to the academy. This comes as the first two classes under Mayor Ed Gainey’s leadership have had only three Black or biracial officers. This should prompt corrective action.
As for the written evaluation, researchers have documented small racial disparities in the MMPI over the decades. Still, the test remains the industry standard. Rather than ditching it, the city should be sure to train the in-person evaluators on the MMPI’s shortcomings.
More pressingly, all of the city’s contracted psychologists are white. While there is no evidence of any intentional bias, given the reality of unconscious bias and the distinctive lived experience of Black Americans, it is imperative for the police force’s gatekeepers to reflect the diversity the city desires and needs in the ranks. Going forward, the Human Resources department should be sure to include people of color in the evaluator rotation.
Lastly, some reporting has indicated that evaluators asked unusual or inappropriate questions of recruits, including whether they own or rent their homes. Given economic disparities among racial groups, these kinds of irrelevant inquiries should be avoided at all costs. The city should provide fuller oversight of the evaluators to ensure their methods are in keeping with current best practices.
Never lower standards
None of these recommendations suggest lowering standards for Pittsburgh police officers. Bringing unqualified or unstable officers onto the force may plug a gap in the short term, but it will make the force less effective and less appealing to qualified candidates in the long run, and less trusted by the public. Lowering standards almost always leads to even lower standards — a vicious cycle that doesn’t solve the problem it was intended to solve.
Law enforcement is a matter of life and death. It is essential to the foundational social values of justice and public trust and safety. The consequences of errors in judgment can propagate across an entire city and country for many years. Screening out people who are not psychologically prepared for such responsibility is a key means of preventing future tragedies, not to mention future public expenses — especially when it’s all but impossible to fire an officer once he or she is hired.
For the 23 candidates rejected this spring, the decision should have been final. The focus must be on directed efforts to recruit high-quality officers, not bending the rules to relieve political pressures — which will prove far more costly in the long run.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.