Making discounted transit fares for Allegheny County residents on SNAP permanent, after a successful pilot program, was a no-brainer. Kudos to County Executive Sara Innamorato for getting this new system, dubbed Allegheny Go, across the finish line.
The devil is in the details, though, and a deeper dive into the pilot data shows that the discounts weren’t quite as effective as the topline numbers suggested. Further, the effectiveness of Allegheny Go will be limited by two choices made by county officials: limiting the fare discount to 50% and requiring a smartphone app to access the system.
The pilot program, announced in late 2022, distributed three kinds of Pittsburgh Regional Transit ConnectCards to about 14,000 SNAP recipients: free-fare cards, half-fare cards and full-fare cards. The Allegheny County Department of Human Services, which funds and manages the discount program, tracked participants’ transit usage to determine the effects of the discounts.
In December, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board parroted figures released by the county indicating that pilot participants who were issued a 50% discount card used buses and light rail four times more often than those who received a full-fare card. But the report released alongside this week’s Allegheny Go announcement complicates that narrative.
The report explains that once some pilot participants realized the card they’d received was no different from a regular ConnectCard, they had no incentive to keep using it. So the number of trips, generated from farecard data, for the no-discount group was artificially low.
The researchers tried to rectify this by asking participants directly about their PRT usage, but the results were unreliable. The best data came from a very small subset of participants — fewer than 300 — who submitted smartphone GPS data, which could be probed to distinguish transit travel from private vehicle travel. This data showed that people with half-fare cards took about 30% more trips, while those with free-fare cards took about 60% more trips.
Read More
In the parlance of statistics, however, the half-fare result is considered “not significant,” which means it doesn’t actually prove the half-fare card made a difference. The free-fare result, however, was “very significant,” leaving no doubt it made a difference.
This data raises questions about the county’s decision to pursue a half measure — that is, permanent 50% discounts rather than 100% discounts. It’s certainly cheaper, but its effects will be limited.
Meanwhile, making the system available via smartphone app resolves the problem of lost ConnectCards, but keeping it smartphone-only makes it inaccessible for riders who don’t have such devices, and who likely need the discount the most.
This all occurs in the context of new data showing that PRT is the only bus service among the top 25 in the U.S. to have lost ridership over the last year. This is a time for bold moves, not timid compromises.
Allegheny Go is still a win for PRT, DHS and Ms. Innamorato. It will relieve price pressure on low-income residents, and boost overall ridership. We hope, however, that county leaders are already considering funding options to expand the program so it can reach its fullest potential.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.