New revelations, communicated to City Council by Controller Rachael Heisler, lay bare city government’s opaque and unaccountable system of informal payments — and the Gainey administration’s scandalous and likely illegal abuse of that system.

Most distressing of all, this conduct would not have come to light were it not for a remarkable (and, itself, unnerving) coincidence: The person arrested for antisemitic vandalism, including a graffiti Nazi slogan, at a private residence in the Mexican War Streets was the beneficiary of the city’s largesse — to the tune of at least $18,000 — using the secretive p-card, or purchase card, system.

In fact, Ms. Heisler reports, one of these payments is due to be approved by City Council on Wednesday. Councilors must hold this and all p-card approvals until a full investigation is completed, and reforms to the system are in place.

P-cards are meant to be used for informal purchases that are not subject to the usual procurement procedures. For instance, a Public Works employee might use a p-card to purchase nuts and bolts at a home improvement store.

Advertise with us

Written policies explicitly forbid p-cards from being used to pay for professional services.

P-card purchases are routinely approved without discussion at City Council standing committee meetings. Even if councilors regularly scrutinized the p-card documentation they receive (they do not), it would be very hard to confidently express suspicion. That’s because all they get is, essentially, a bank statement.

As for public accountability, it’s much worse: There is no public database of p-card expenses. That information is held only by the Office of Management and Budget, which has behaved consistently unscrupulously under the leadership of Jake Pawlak and is still the subject of a law enforcement inquiry into its procurement of the Matrix police staffing study.

That means nine overworked members of council are the only line of defense against p-card abuse. Clearly the Gainey administration discovered this weakness.

According to Ms. Heisler’s letter, the city has been consistently paying Mario Ashkar, the suspect in the antisemitic vandalism — including within a year after leaving the city’s service, a violation of state ethics rules. The $1,200 payments are under the auspices of the Parks and Recreation Department, and sources confirm that they regard services in support of the city’s farmers’ market program.

Advertise with us

Shockingly, in violation of every standard of good government and good sense, these payments were made not only without documentation, but to a PayPal account. Ms. Heisler’s letter indicates that “PayPal” was indicated on the approval request submitted to council. It falls on council that no one caught this sooner.

But the abuse of the system falls on the Gainey administration, and particularly OMB. We expect there will be a movement to blame Parks and Recreation chief Kathryn Vargas, but this would be unjust and a cowardly failure to take responsibility. The payments were approved and submitted (and obscured, using PayPal) by Mr. Pawlak’s office.

Councilors must follow through on Ms. Heisler’s recommendation to hold Wednesday’s p-card approvals. And then they must move to ensure itemized receipts and explanations for p-card purchases are submitted to OMB and the Controller’s Office, and subsequently made public.

Anything less than this would be to acquiesce in the abuse of city government, their own abuse and the abuse of the taxpayers of Pittsburgh.