In the wake of another spate of youth violence and disorder in Downtown Pittsburgh, the first response is coming from the Bureau of Police, with increased patrols announced for the Golden Triangle. While law enforcement does have a role to play in disrupting and responding to fights and more dangerous activity — a handgun was found in the bag of one Market Square brawler last week — ultimately the most effective long-term deterrent to youth violence is providing safe and constructive things for young people to do, and places for them to be.
This was City Council’s insight over a year ago, when the legislature collaborated with the Mayor’s Office to create the Advisory Committee for Youth and Family Resources. The idea: collect insights from around the city to inform a plan to build out city-run youth community centers. The problem: since last February, when the committee members were named, the group has met, at most, twice.
As a result, Pittsburgh has nothing resembling a plan for the summertime, when school is out and police resources are stretched even more thinly than usual. It is yet another example of a city government that gestures toward results without actually accomplishing any.
Last year, the Editorial Board argued that the composition of the advisory committee was not auspicious. Rather than bringing in current leaders in the area of youth resources and social services, or young people who have benefited from such organizations, the panel consisted entirely of elected and appointed city officials. Besides bringing no new ideas or experiences to the table, the members are already part of so many boards and committees that it was all but certain nothing would come of it.
Of course that’s exactly what happened. While no one expected the committee to solve the problem or youth violence and aimlessness immediately, if it had been better organized it could have laid foundations that could be put to use today. Instead, no progress has been made, and the city is right where it was before this ‘urgent’ conversation began nearly 18 months ago.
Youth resources centers are sensitive and complicated operations (and they aren’t cheap). They require more than a video game console and a pool table — such weak attempts would simply become new centers of disorder.
To be successful, they need firm leadership and compassionate supervision; access to counseling and other trauma-informed therapies; partnerships with workforce organizations to teach essential skills; and, of course, the right equipment to be genuinely fun for today’s young people.
It was always going to be a heavy lift for a city government strapped for cash and for creativity. Doing nothing at all has only set Pittsburgh back further, leaving the city grasping for answers.
And when city leaders grasp for answers, they’re likely to grab the easiest tool at hand: the police.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.