Magisterial District Judge Xander Orenstein has captured headlines once again. This time, the Lawrenceville-based judge applied nonmonetary bail conditions to a defendant arrested after a dangerous police chase on April 9. As a result, Hermas Craddock of Sharpsburg is free until his May 1 court date.

But the controversy — as with previous bail decisions by the judge, such as the electronic monitoring impotently applied to an accused drug kingpin — points toward larger problems in the Allegheny County criminal justice system. While it may be emotionally satisfying (and politically expedient) to pin bad outcomes on a single rogue judge, placing those outcomes in context sheds a somewhat different, and more revealing, light.

The truth is that the county’s arraignment system is obscure and haphazard, and District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. has declined to use the power at his disposal to monitor that system and to hold it accountable. Mr. Zappala should not stoke outrage against judges whose decisions he has declined to influence in the proper venue: the courtroom.

The decisions made by Judge Orenstein, who uses they/them pronouns, are often unorthodox, and are open to sharp criticism. But the voters of their judicial district will have a chance to pass judgment on the judge’s work when they are up for reelection in 2027.

Advertise with us

Life-changing choices

Those voters should keep in mind that their decision will have effects beyond Pittsburgh’s Sixth and Ninth Wards: Each of the 46 Allegheny County magisterial district judges does shifts at the Downtown arraignment court.

That means every neighborhood judge will, at some point, be responsible for some of the heaviest decisions in the county criminal justice system: how to adjudicate bail for defendants in their very first appearance in court. At these preliminary arraignments, judges have enormous latitude to decide whether to remand the defendant to the county jail, or to release the defendant under a variety of conditions. The most familiar of these is cash bail, in which the defendant submits funds (or has a bail bondsman submit funds on his or her behalf) that are refunded when he or she appears in court as scheduled.

Each of these decisions could have momentous impacts on public safety, past and future victims, and the life of the defendant. The judge has access to the charging documents, past criminal records and the recommendation of the county pretrial services department. Beyond that, the judge is alone, with only his or her common sense and philosophy of justice to rely on.

Sometimes a defense attorney, private or public, will appear to advocate on a client’s behalf. What is unusual — and perhaps unique within Pennsylvania — is that the district attorney’s office does not send a prosecutor to argue for its interpretation of the public good. That also means Mr. Zappala’s office is unaware of bail decisions until after they happen.

Withholding judgment

Judge Orenstein’s bail decision in the Craddock case certainly looks imprudent, even dangerous. This was the defendant’s 42nd time in Allegheny County courts, dating back to 2005, when he was 18 years old. The charges from the April 9 incident include attempting to ram multiple police cars. Mr. Craddock was already out on $25,000 bail on 2022 weapons charges.

Advertise with us

If nothing else, Judge Orenstein should have realized that the public fallout of this decision would damage their own judicial credibility, and the credibility of their reform causes. No one would have thought it unjust to remand Mr. Craddock to jail. This is another example of what we have previously described as “a level of naïveté unbecoming of a magistrate.”

Still, no one was in that courtroom with Judge Orenstein, and no one knows what they knew about the case. For instance, the judge may have had information about Mr. Craddock’s mental health that made them believe that the Allegheny County Jail, with its abysmal record for mental health care, would be overall a more dangerous place for the defendant, and for those he would come in contact with. That judgment would likely still be wrong, but it might not be irrational.

Further, many of the facts should raise more serious questions about the typical way justice is handled in Allegheny County than about one decision by one judge.

Dereliction of duty

Take the fact that this was Mr. Craddock’s 42nd preliminary arraignment. That does argue in favor of remanding him to jail — but it should also demonstrate that business as usual is not working. The same goes for the outstanding $25,000 bond. That should demonstrate the ineffectiveness of cash bail, and encourage leaders to consider alternative approaches that actually serve justice and public safety.

Mr. Zappala has asked for a review of Judge Orenstein’s bail decision. That’s good. But it would have been better if one of Mr. Zappala’s lawyers were in the courtroom during the arraignment to present that argument first. The result may not have changed, but at least the people would have had a representative at the table, and the review process could have begun more quickly.

Advertise with us

Instead, as usual, the DA’s Office was reactive, rather than proactive.

As for Judge Orenstein, they are restrained by their code of conduct and by prudence from speaking out on cases like this. They have no voice. We wish the county’s legal associations would say a word in their defense, or at least a word of explanation on their behalf. Threats to judges are increasing around the country, and when no one raises a finger to restrain a public pile-on, it leaves the impression that it can be open season on controversial judges.

Xander Orenstein may be more suited to the role of activist, rather than judge. But the problems with Allegheny County’s criminal justice system go far beyond one judge: Above all, Stephen Zappala must take his own share of the responsibility for abandoning the arraignment process.