Office to residential conversions are the best shot to return social and economic vibrancy to Downtown, but they’re too expensive for developers to pursue on their own. Tax abatements are a way to adjust the financial calculus in favor of development, thereby increasing long-term tax receipts for the City of Pittsburgh without spending any taxpayer money or losing any current revenue.
That, in a nutshell, is why Mayor Ed Gainey and Pittsburgh City Council should approve Councilman Bobby Wilson’s legislation to expand tax abatement incentives for Downtown development. The city’s current Local Economic Revitalization Tax Assistance (LERTA) program was a good first step, but it’s not enough to clear the path for the projects Downtown needs.
Mr. Wilson announced the plan Monday alongside three other members of council, leaders from the Allegheny-Fayette Labor Council and SEIU 32BJ (a building service workers union that is administratively and politically distinct from SEIU Healthcare) and representatives of developers and the Pittsburgh Downtown Partnership. It would remove the $250,000 cap on tax abatements for residential conversions and job-creating developments Downtown, while reducing affordable housing requirements to 10% of units affordable at 80% of area median income.
These tax abatements will not worsen the city’s fragile budget situation. Just the opposite: The collapse of the Downtown property tax base makes development incentives all the more important. Indeed, a recent real estate report obtained by the Post-Gazette’s Mark Belko revealed that Downtown office vacancies could rise from 30% to nearly 50% in four years.
The abatements will reduce city property taxes by half for 10 years only on the increases to assessed value attributable to construction. That means it’s impossible for any property owner to pay less in taxes after construction than they’re currently paying. The city is only giving up half of an increase in property tax revenue that would not happen at all if the abatement were not in place.
In other words, there’s no risk. Gulf Tower owner Rugby Realty estimates, for instance, that its planned conversion would generate $37 million in tax revenue (including wage and hotel taxes) over a decade, against a $7 million abatement.
The Gainey administration has often treated developers as adversaries to bring to heel, rather than potential partners whose interests can, through a candid and collaborative process, often align with the city’s. But this proposal poses no financial risk to the city and no unearned profits to developers.
Further, developers doing office-to-residential conversions bear unusually high costs. These are often more expensive than building from scratch, and involve improvements to public infrastructure, such as utilities.
The proposed abatement — whose terms still lag those in peer cities, like Cleveland’s 100% abatements for 15 years — is a way of helping developers achieve their goal of profitability while the city achieves its goal of an enlarged tax base not just from the projects themselves, but from enhancements to Downtown’s economic and social environment as a whole.
The alternative is not a victory for the public good against private greed. The alternative is the status quo of stagnation and decline, where nobody wins anything at all.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.