Last week, tech magazine WIRED published leaked coordinates from ShotSpotter revealing the locations of acoustic sensors used to detect gunfire in communities across the U.S. The maps act as a kind of Rorschach test for the controversial program, which has existed in Pittsburgh since 2015, and is viewed by some as a helpful police triage tool, and by others as a way to justify overpolicing poor and minority neighborhoods.

The microphones cover nearly a third of the city, including the Upper and Lower Hill District, South Side, the entire North Side, Allentown and Hazelwood. Overlaying a map of redlined neighborhoods, where de facto segregation was enforced in the mid 20th century, reveals stunning overlaps. But is ShotSpotter a helpful technology that just happens to be helpful in historically underserved neighborhoods — or is it part of keeping those neighborhoods on the margins?

There is some evidence for the former contention. In 2019 and 2020, for instance, Pittsburgh police and paramedics were able to help victims in 13 shootings that were only detected via ShotSpotter, and not reported via 911 calls. Unfortunately, this is the most recent data the city has released.

Broader studies of ShotSpotter’s effectiveness are complex and sometimes contradictory. One report, from 2019, explored eight years’ worth of shooting data in Camden, N.J. The study found the technology did indeed allow for faster transport of shooting victims, who also got more rapid blood transfusions and were less likely to need resuscitation. Another massive study, including 17 years of nationwide data, concluded that ShotSpotter didn’t have a significant impact on homicide rates or arrests.

Advertise with us

But ShotSpotter has mostly become controversial because of its use as evidence in court, most egregiously in a Chicago case uncovered by the Associated Press. In that incident, a ShotSpotter alert was used to justify keeping a grandfather who had witnessed a shooting in police custody for nearly a year. The innocent man, who had actually tried to save the victim, was eventually released when a judge finally noticed the lack of any other evidence. Chicago has since terminated its ShotSpotter contracts.

Pittsburgh, meanwhile, continues to spend over $1.1 million per year to use the program, and is even contemplating expanding sensors to Carrick, largely due to clamoring from Carrick residents. The city’s contract expires at the end of next year.

The Department of Public Safety should use that time to gather data and to develop a public dashboard to assess ShotSpotter effectiveness. Given the Pittsburgh Police’s deepening staffing crisis, the top question the city should seek to answer is: Does ShotSpotter allow the bureau to effectively target its limited resources, or is it forcing officers to chase scattershot gunfire reports when they could be using their time more effectively?

Until then, ShotSpotter will continue to be a Rorschach test for one’s views of law enforcement and racial justice. Better data, specific to Pittsburgh’s own personnel and geographic situation, will allow that test to resolve into a clearer picture, which will determine the technology’s future in the city.