Pennsylvania should join the growing number of states — currently 26, including neighbors New York and Maryland — that allow certified registered nurse practitioners (CRNPs) to practice independently to the full extent of their training. Measures to liberate CRNPs are percolating in both the state House (HB 1825) and Senate (SB 25), with support across partisan and ideological lines. It’s time to get it across the finish line.
Nurse practitioners, who must complete either a masters degree or doctorate, exist in a middle ground between nurses and physicians. They can examine patients, diagnose conditions, prescribe medications and order testing. However, in Pennsylvania they are not permitted to practice independently: They must have a signed collaboration agreement with a physician.
This introduces unnecessary administrative friction, not to mention cost, into the health care system. Besides the hassle of finding a willing physician — sometimes it’s a member of a group practice, sometimes it’s an off-site, or even across-the-state, doctor — CRNPs have to pay for their collaboration agreements, sometimes in the thousands of dollars per month.
While the theory is that the physician is providing hands-on oversight, in many if not most cases, the physician is merely providing a very expensive signature. In fact, there are online services dedicated to matching CRNPs with collaborating doctors whom they will likely never meet.
At the same time, Pennsylvania is suffering from a lack of health care professionals, especially in rural areas. Given its diverse geography and demography, Pennsylvania has an unusually high number of medically underserved areas and populations. For instance, the March of Dimes reports that nearly half of rural Pennsylvania women live more than 30 minutes from a hospital with maternity care.
But the state does have more than 16,000 CRNPs. Not all of them will immediately sever ties with their collaborating physicians — either bill would allow such agreements to continue — nor will they all move to Elk or Fulton counties. Even so, freeing them from the burden of expensive and unnecessary collaboration agreements will nearly immediately increase the number of independent health care professionals in the commonwealth, increasing access and likely lowering some costs.
Neither bill expands nurse practitioners’ official “scope of practice;” rather, they allow CRNPs the independence their training has prepared them for. To make absolutely sure, however, both bills do include a requirement for three years, or 3,600 hours, working under a collaborative agreement before going independent.
The bills have support from both parties and a variety of health care organizations, from the Hospital and Health System Association of Pennsylvania to the Pennsylvania Rural Health Association. This is a rare policy where even UPMC and SEIU Healthcare PA are on the same side.
SB 25 is the more likely vehicle, given that 35 of 50 senators are already co-sponsors. We urge Sen. Pat Stefano, R-Fayette, to bring the bill to a vote in the Consumer Protection & Professional Licensure Committee he chairs, and we urge the Republican Senate leadership to quickly bring it to the floor.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.