A lack of coordination of Pittsburgh’s homeless services nearly resulted in tragedy on Sunday evening, when a man trapped in flood waters had to be rescued from the Mon Wharf. Despite multiple alerts from the National Weather Service, the deluge has caught city and county agencies flat-footed, with dozens of people left at risk in multiple flood-prone sites around the city.

While no one is confirmed to have been hurt or killed by the flooding, the makeshift homes and belongings of around 40 people have been ruined or swept away in the flood. The incident has become another example of the failure of planning and coordination among the region’s homeless service agencies.

On Monday afternoon — nearly 24 hours after flood waters began inundating the wharf — the Allegheny County Department of Human Services (DHS) declared a Code Blue. The designation, meant to open extra shelter space when temperatures drop below 26 degrees, is now being used to open overflow space for people displaced by the flooding.

But the county should have anticipated the disaster sooner, and facilitated getting people and belongings out of flood zones. Going forward, DHS should make a forecast river crest of 19 feet an automatic trigger for a Code Blue and its additional resources.

Advertise with us

Near tragedy

On Sunday evening, it was a Post-Gazette Editorial Board member who alerted emergency responders to the growing crisis.

The editor visited the Mon Wharf encampment late on Sunday evening, and found water much higher than other recent crests, with one person stranded and several others at risk. The 20-tent encampment, built into the highest recesses of the wharf underneath the Parkway East and the Smithfield Street Bridge, was quickly submerging. Anyone left in the camp found themselves cut off from the pedestrian ramp, pushed toward the concrete walls of the highway behind them. The stranded man was rescued via the highway above and directed to a shelter.

Efforts to secure the camp during previous crests using large tarps distributed by outreach workers were rendered useless as water continued to rise. An entire mattress, an overturned kayak, syringes, blankets, coats and all the trappings of life for those who were living at the encampment are now underwater or floating down the Ohio.

It represents a total loss of outreach materials and months of supplies, as well as significant pollution for the waterways. Dozens of people are now staying in overnight shelters with nothing to their name. They are now completely dependent on the county and its resources for help.

No coordination

In recent weeks, authorities had been more attentive to the Mon Wharf encampment. On Jan. 10, the NWS forecasted a crest above the wharf flood level of 18 feet, and authorities evacuated the area — though residents quickly filtered back into their makeshift homes, as the waters only lapped the wharf.

Advertise with us

An overnight crest on Saturday also didn’t seriously affect the camp, perhaps resulting in complacency among both residents and authorities. But at 9 p.m. on Sunday, further rainfall and snowmelt brought the river to 20 feet and rising. The wharf, along with several other encampment areas, was completely inundated by Monday morning, and waters eventually crested around 23 feet: the highest since Feb. 9, 2019.

According to the NWS, however, it only takes about 19.5 feet for the Mon Wharf to flood completely. No one should have been at the wharf, and ideally all belongings would have already been removed.

As the city has learned time and again, clearing homeless encampments in a dignified manner is a challenging and time-consuming process. But banning unhoused people from the wharf and other flood-prone areas entirely is unrealistic with homelessness at peak levels. City officials must formulate a plan for the temporary removal and storage of belongings when high water is predicted — minimizing the damage of these floods while maintaining realistic standards.

Flood waters will likely recede on Wednesday. Officials now have several days to formulate cleanup efforts and draft future plans. The natural place for such these projects is the Office of Community Health and Safety (OCHS), which was created for exactly this kind of street outreach and coordination. OCHS can and should serve as point of contact for city, county and private agencies in responding to dangerous conditions for the unhoused — however, significant staff turnover and Gainey administration suspicion of a Peduto-era office has limited its effectiveness.

At the county level, the Monday afternoon declaration of a Code Blue, which opens additional shelter space and extends shelter hours, came far too late — due at least in part to the lack of a single point of coordination, as OCHS had been for outreach within Pittsburgh. One lesson of this near-tragedy is that high water should always trigger a Code Blue.

Advertise with us

Patching holes

Early on Monday, another Post-Gazette Editorial Board member was flagged down at the Point by Patrick, 18, from the North Side, who said a homeless camp was about to float down the Allegheny. They ultimately pulled two tents, full of soaked blankets and clothes, to higher ground.

“Why didn’t somebody do something?” the Good Samaritan asked.

The truth is, many individuals and organizations are doing something, continuing to perform the heroic work of serving Pittsburgh’s unhoused. For instance, on Sunday night Ben Talik, program manager for the city’s Reaching Out On The Streets (ROOTS) outreach program, waded into flood waters himself to ensure no remaining tents were occupied.

But it should never have come to that point, when so many people’s shelter and earthly possessions were ruined or washed away. Professionals like Mr. Talik and everyday citizens like Patrick are patching a system of care that is simply not working.

It’s clear that between the City of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County, no single person or group is taking primary responsibility for keeping unhoused people safe in dangerous conditions. That must change, because a journalist won’t always be there to call 911 for help.