The Pittsburgh Land Bank has achieved startling successes since being liberated by a combination of state and city legislative action. After acquiring only a few properties and selling none at all in its first nine years of existence, PLB has brought 70 parcels onto its books in the last three months alone, and has sold six of them, returning them to the tax rolls.
This growth reflects the remarkable competence of the bank’s manager, Sally Stadelman, and shows that with a combination of smart policy and the right personnel, real progress can be made in city government — even in one of its most challenging tasks, eliminating blight.
Even so, there are lingering issues holding PLB back that, if resolved, could further enhance its portfolio. The land bank still needs an Intergovernmental Cooperation Agreement (previously known as the Three Taxing Bodies Agreement) to lower the costs of clearing tax liens. This will likely require a full complement of board members to ensure sustainable long-term cooperation among the three often fractious taxing bodies.
Most of all, however, the land bank needs more staff and dedicated funding to reach its full potential — a potential the land bank has amply demonstrated over the last few months.
Three-way deal
A land bank serves its purpose by acquiring vacant and blighted properties hard to sell on the open market because of their expensive tax liens — that is, backed up property taxes — attached to them. The land bank has the legal and financial means to clear those liens, and return the property to the market unencumbered, thereby returning it to the tax rolls.
It’s most efficient, financially and legally, for the land bank to operate with an agreement among the taxing bodies — Allegheny County, the City of Pittsburgh and Pittsburgh Public Schools — that allows back taxes to be cleared all at once and at a discount. This costs the taxing bodies some of the taxes they’re owed right now, while allowing the bank to acquire and sell more properties more quickly. For the taxing bodies, it’s a short-term loss for medium-term gain.
In all likelihood, the only way to secure such an agreement will be for Mayor Ed Gainey to appoint representatives of the county and the school district on the land bank’s board. A word of caution, however: The most cash-strapped and least well-run of the taxing bodies — the school district — is generally the most suspicious of giving up today’s taxes for tomorrow’s windfall. It would be better for the land bank to continue as is than for it to be hamstrung by a restrictive agreement with PPS, or by an obstructive PPS board member.
About face
For its first nine years, the Pittsburgh Land Bank was itself a blight on city government. A combination of inconsistent funding, inconstant leadership and, most of all, a restrictive legislative environment nearly smothered the institution before it could take its first steps. Fifteen months ago, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board threw up its hands and recommended the whole thing be scrapped, and a new version raised in its place.
Since then, however, the land bank’s shackles have been removed one at a time. In August, after many months of delays caused by the intransigence of Councilwoman Deb Gross, City Council finally approved a measure allowing PLB to acquire properties currently in the city’s embarrassing inventory of 13,000 properties, many of which are in serious disrepair. A month later, Gov. Josh Shapiro signed a law championed by state Sen. Wayne Fontana that streamlined land banks’ ability to clear tax liens from property titles, which is essential to their ability to return properties to the tax rolls.
And so by the fall, the land bank was acquiring dozens of properties at a time, plowing through a list Ms. Stadelman and her staff — a single assistant — had compiled. Her quick work has demonstrated that the land bank can be a transformative institution for Pittsburgh — if it’s given what it needs to succeed.
Sustainable resources
The original plan for Pittsburgh’s American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds, proposed by former Mayor Bill Peduto and approved by City Council, included $10 million over five years for the land bank. Given the land bank’s failure to launch, that appropriation was dropped to $7 million, for good reason, by the Gainey administration during 2022.
Unfortunately, however, Mr. Gainey further slashed the ARPA funding to $3.5 million just as the PLB was finally getting going. Ms. Stadelman had a detailed plan for acquiring and maintaining 390 properties with that $7 million, which has now been cut to 167 through 2026. While Mr. Gainey may have been concerned the land bank couldn’t spend the full appropriation before the 2026 deadline, its first few months of activity should have proven otherwise. The Mayor and City Council should strongly consider restoring ARPA funds to the land bank: By getting blighted properties improved and back on the tax rolls, it’s one of the best investments of federal funds the city can make.
Happily, the land bank’s budget for its ARPA funds includes additional staffing, which will remove pressure from Ms. Stadelman and allow the bank to work through its list of properties more efficiently. The staffing funds run out, however, at the end of this year: It’s essential that Mr. Gainey establish consistent city funding for the PLB, both for staffing and for properties, because ARPA won’t last forever.
While its roots go deeper than this administration, a successful land bank could be remembered as one of the most important legacies of Mr. Gainey’s years in office. Whether that success is short-lived or sustainable will be, in large part, up to him.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.