Proposed changes by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) to cut down on exorbitant overdraft charges are a welcome, if overdue, update to curb big banks’ predatory practices.

The banks, however, will likely fight the new regulations for years to come. Stuck between the federal government and giant banks, what are consumers left to do?

One option: Leave. Financial technology, or fintech, has opened the door to online and mobile banking options that offer fewer services, but also fewer fees, than traditional banks. While they aren’t for everyone — they generally focus on specific demographics, such as students or freelancers — they do provide essential competition for banks that have dined out on overdrafts fees for decades.

Overdraft fees are essentially the price bank customers pay for a service: the bank covering for you if you spend more than you have. They were first implemented in the 1990s as a way for customers to avoid the expense and hassle of a bounced check. (For our younger readers, a check “bounces” when the payee goes to cash it, and the payer doesn’t have enough money to cover it.) Since then, however, they’ve become ubiquitous as the discipline of balancing a checkbook (we’ll let our younger readers ask their parents about that one) has faded, and new technology has allowed consumers to make more transactions, including easily forgotten automatic withdrawals, faster than ever.

Advertise with us

Which means it’s easier to lose track, and to incur a nasty overdraft fee. It also means the original purpose of the fees is mostly obsolete, and now they’re a convenience fee to avoid getting a card declined at the grocery store — or a tax on families who struggle to make ends meet.

Today, overdraft fees average $27 a pop. One-fifth of those who regularly overdraft don’t have credit scores, shutting them out from most traditional loans, according to the CFPB. A 2021 FinHealth report showed that poorer households spent 13% of their income on fees and interest, compared with 1% for financially healthy households.

Profits from the fees peaked in 2019 at a cartoonish $11.7 billion dollars. In 2017, the CEO of a bank in Minnesota named his yacht the “Overdraft.” His bank was promptly sued for predatory policies regarding, you guessed it, overdraft programs.

Since 2019’s peak profitability, however, overdraft fees have been in decline. During the COVID pandemic, government stimulus checks bolstered bank accounts while fintech options continued to expand, and the Biden Administration joined Congress in setting its sights on “junk fees.” In response to market and government pressure, some large banks began lowering fees, giving customers a grace period for repayment or only charging fees if the overdrafts exceeded a certain threshold.

Even though overdraft fees are waning, Mr. Biden’s CFPB is still right to try to regulate them. Overdrafts shouldn’t be a source of profit: They should be capped at the cost of administering the program, plus the (small) cost of the risk the bank takes on.

The banks are vowing to fight the new rules — but that should just encourage more customers to take their money elsewhere.