By now, the purported failure of Pittsburgh-based Astrobotic’s moon mission has been well-documented. Roughly an hour after the company’s six-foot lunar lander separated from the Vulcan Centaur Rocket that propelled it into orbit above Cape Canaveral, Fla., a stuck valve caused a fuel leak that dashed the mission’s hopes for a soft moon landing.
It was a blow for space enthusiasts nationwide. Astrobotic’s Peregrine lander would have marked many firsts: the first-ever private company reaching the moon; the first NASA Commercial Lunar Payload Services partner to make the trip; and, for younger generations, the first living memory of American lunar contact. For others, the excitement was more sentimental: Hundreds of authors and artists contributed small payloads with the hope that they’d reach solid celestial ground — a future that is now uncertain.
But this moment also calls for perspective. Though the mission won’t be able to land on the moon as planned, scientific inquiry is rarely a matter of everything going as planned, and often depends on creatively making the best of bad situation. Within hours, Peregrine’s technicians began strategizing for a new mission with new goals. Scientists and students booted up the instruments on board to assess their functionality in space, establishing connection with ground crews through NASA's Deep Space Network of antennas. And they worked, allowing the craft to collect rare and valuable data from the 238,900 mile expanse between the Earth and the moon.
All this information will be a huge asset for Astrobotic as it plans its next moon mission, Griffin, in November 2024. Spaceflight, like all attempts to push the limits of humanity, has always been about trial and error. Before this latest propulsion failure for Peregrine, for instance, its launch was delayed because the Vulcan rocket tasked with bringing it into earth orbit exploded during a launch. It’s a high-risk, high-reward game — but above all it rewards boldness and inventiveness, and engineers and scientists have learned how to extract the most information from every anomaly.
Space is not a forgiving frontier. Seeing the Peregrine mission fall short of its goals is disheartening, but it marks only the beginning of a new era space exploration. Like so many awesome human endeavors, while this mission failed in its appointed task, it will likely be remembered much more for everything that went right — especially the clever and hard work to make the best of the malfunction — than for what went wrong.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.