A proposed affiliation between Pittsburgh-based UPMC and the Washington Hospital, which serves Washington and Greene Counties, highlights the struggles of rural health care systems across America. For the sake of patients and workers, who rarely do better when health care systems consolidate, the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s office and the Federal Trade Commission are right to scrutinize such bids.
But that scrutiny must be based in reality, and must not verge into obstruction, which would hurt precisely the communities state and federal agencies are supposed to protect. And the reality, as in too many rural hospitals across America, is that if the UPMC deal is delayed or torpedoed, the Washington Hospital will begin to shutter key services, and will soon close in its entirety.
The challenges facing rural health care in America are just as complicated and abstruse as those facing the entire health care system, only more acute. Two data points, however, are most important: The reimbursement rates paid to health care facilities by the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services do not keep up with inflation, and rural hospitals serve a disproportionate number of people on Medicare and Medicaid.
For the nonprofit Washington Hospital, that includes 60% of its patients. At the same time, according to the American Medical Association, CMS reimbursement rates have declined 26% due to inflation since 2001. That only got worse during the high inflation of 2022 to 2023, turning the Washington Hospital’s healthy excess income into an unsustainable deficit.
The hospital reports that, if current trends continue, it will burn through its reserves during 2025. To stave off that outcome, it likely will have to close low-margin services, such as maternity care, this year. That would leave southwest Pennsylvania without labor-and-delivery services between Jefferson Hills and Morgantown.
This is why the Washington Hospital, despite a 125-year legacy of independence, sought an affiliation agreement with a larger system last year. UPMC’s bid included a commitment to keep all the Washington Hospital’s facilities open for the next decade, along with a $300 million promise of capital improvements over ten years.
On the flip side, studies show that prices go up and wages go down when health care competition declines. Everyone, especially responsible government agencies, should look at mergers with suspicion.
But that does not justify treating UPMC and Washington differently than other bids. Both systems report to the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that the FTC has asked them for millions of documents, which take months to gather, and will be impossible for the agency’s employees to sift through in a timely manner. The state Attorney General’s office, meanwhile, has drawn out its document requests over several months, despite both hospitals’ indicating a November 2023 target closing date.
As a result, a process that should take months is set to take years. During that time, the Washington Hospital will wither on the vine. And that would hurt exactly the people — patients and workers — the government claims to be helping.
Consolidation is not good for rural health care, but closing is worse. And until there is a thorough reform of America’s broken health care system, those will be the only two options on the table.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.