The pandemic forever altered the way American businesses use their offices, especially those in urban downtowns. Nearly four years out from COVID’s onset, real estate reports show that Downtown Pittsburgh’s office space is still 20.5% vacant.

And the occupied space isn’t being used efficiently, either. The percentage of workers frequenting the central business district is hovering around 60% of pre-pandemic levels. This downturn is also affecting restaurants and tourism, and as a result, overall Downtown activity has dropped nearly 30% compared to 2019.

With work patterns having apparently changed permanently, it’s unlikely that the city’s downtown will ever have the number of daily workers it did just a few years ago. This leaves offices built and designed for businesses empty. What can be done with the space? And how can that use contribute to a thriving mixed-use downtown, with restaurants, businesses and residential buildings as well as office space?

The most obvious use is to turn empty office space into housing, a strategy some developers have already embraced. In January, the city joined in, launching a program to incentivize companies to convert empty office space into affordable housing using federal coronavirus funds.

Advertise with us

The incentive program has only attracted one funded project, at the Triangle Building on Liberty Avenue, and is still nowhere near saturating Downtown’s housing market. Naturally, the pilot program revealed that pandemic workplace fallout is too complicated to be solved with one simple incentive program.

An investigation by the Brookings Institute came to the same conclusion: office-to-residential conversions in city centers are a good idea, but are generally more complex, with success more difficult than it appears at first.

First of all, office space, far from becoming obsolete, is still an important part of a Downtown ecosystem. Workers are utilizing these spaces, even if only a few days a week or for fewer overall hours. Businesses are often opting for newer, smaller spaces as well, leaving outdated, oversized offices in the dust.

Second, converting offices into living spaces presents logistical challenges, especially for older buildings. Offices have a smaller, denser footprint than even the smallest living spaces, so converted buildings necessarily offer fewer units than buildings built for apartments.

Third, the economics of these conversions are complex. The Pittsburgh program failed to attract applicants for months because its affordable housing requirements made the economics unfeasible – at least according to developers. New tweaks to the program’s funding caps have attracted the new Triangle project, and at least seven others are in the pipeline, according to reporting from WESA.

Advertise with us

Like so many of the proposed solutions to today’s housing shortage, this fix will only ever be able address a small portion of the city’s housing needs. It will inevitably be just one part of the city’s larger strategy to revitalize Downtown.

It also won’t address a larger issue: building housing, of all kinds, must be made easier through zoning and incentive changes. Nevertheless, office to residential conversions are a good sign for Downtown’s upcoming, probably inevitable, mixed-use future.