A bill broadening the scope of factors that judges may use when deciding custody hearings has been moving through Harrisburg for several years with little success. The measure, called Kayden’s Law, is humane and compassionate — but legislators and advocates should not be surprised if it doesn’t change much about child custody decisions in Pennsylvania.

The bill is meant to give judges more factors they can consider when making these decisions, especially regarding abuse. The list of offenses reviewed during custody hearings would be expanded to include charges or convictions for animal cruelty, recklessly endangering another person or interfering with custody proceedings.

However, judges in Pennsylvania are already required to weigh 16 broad factors when deciding these cases, including parental stability, overall family dynamics, relationships between guardians and the preferences of the children themselves. Parents are also required to submit a slew of documents, including their own criminal histories, for consideration. While increasing the scope of charges and convictions to be explicitly considered is a good idea in theory, judges already have significant leeway to interpret parents’ criminal histories holistically.

The basis for Kayden’s Law is harrowing: In 2018, an elementary school student from Bucks County was beaten to death by her father during an unsupervised visit. Her mother had fought a years-long custody battle to protect her from the father, who had made death threats against other family members and bitten off a man’s ear during a fight.

Advertise with us

For his violent behavior, he had been banned from Kayden’s school. Yet the judge in the case didn’t think his volatile behavior extended to Kayden herself, and this naivete proved deadly.

This tragedy spawned the first version of Kayden’s Law — that did not pass — which would have created a presumption against custody for parents with histories of abuse in the household, no matter how long ago. The proposal was a lesson in the dangers of good intentions alone.

As the ACLU of Pennsylvania pointed out in opposing the measure, it would have denied unsupervised contact between many parents — especially mothers — and their children over long-ago and often very minor violations. The commonwealth has a very loose definition of child abuse and neglect that can be used to criminalize poverty by citing parents for “offenses” like failing to install proper baby gates. Such a conviction could have, years or decades later, triggered unjust separation from a teenaged child.

Altogether, the original version of Kayden’s Law would have significantly limited judges’ discretion in deciding complex, high-stakes custody cases, leading to more traumatic outcomes for children.

The newer version of Kayden’s Law rightly removed the overbroad approach, but in so doing became largely redundant.

Advertise with us

To emphasize the seriousness with which the commonwealth takes child abuse generally, and particularly in the case of custody disputes, it will do no harm to pass Kayden’s Law into law. But its effects will not be all its boosters hope for.

Clarification: This editorial has been edited to adjust the description of the presumption against custody included in the 2022 version of Kayden’s Law.