A two-year fight for transparency for the victims of the Fern Hollow bridge disaster has once again been hampered by the City of Pittsburgh’s unwillingness to release vital documents. A judge this week ordered the city to release some information to victims, but the bridge inspection reports that will demonstrate the dilapidation of the bridge will remain confidential, at least for now.

The city justifies this by citing two laws — federal and state — meant to protect highway and traffic accident investigations by keeping infrastructure vulnerabilities under wraps. However, these laws don’t account for situations where the protected structure no longer exists due to, for example, a collapse caused by decades of negligence. And the city’s cynical attempt to hide behind them doesn’t account for the public safety benefits of transparency.

The timing of this argument is crucial, coming just before the two-year statute of limitations runs out for 10 people injured in the collapse to make claims against the negligent parties. The victims need to file before Jan. 28, 2024, and the information the city is hiding is essential to their case.

Presiding Judge Phil Ignelzi, who called the entire proceeding “needless” and “bureaucratic,” ordered the city to release 311 records and internal emails — obviously public records the city shamefully fought to keep secret — but stopped short of ordering the release of the inspection reports. He didn’t seem to think the city’s overall arguments were particularly compelling, however.

Advertise with us

“Why would the federal government give two doodle-doos whether I release this information?” he said during Tuesday’s hearing.

There is a weak argument that revealing Fern Hollow’s weakness may provide helpful information to bad actors. But unless bad guys find new proprietary ways to accelerate the corrosion of bridge elements over decades under negligent oversight, it’s safe to say that the Fern Hollow bridge collapse won’t be replicated in an act of slow-burn terrorism. Releasing more information to the public about the bridges they use every day is at least as important for public safety.

And for public accountability. Fern Hollow was a whole-system failure across multiple administrations. The more the public knows about that failure, the more likely it can be avoided in the future.

In other major disasters, such as the 2021 Champlain Tower South condominium collapse in Surfside, Fla., local officials were much more forthcoming. There, the city had no problem immediately releasing building documents, internal emails and inspections documents regarding the structure. There are other condominium buildings that follow similar floor plans, but the city didn’t argue that revealing the documents somehow presented a threat to public safety.

Again: Revealing them enhanced public safety.

Here, Judge Ignelzi was forced to comply with state and federal statutes, despite the inapplicability of their logic to a collapsed structure. But the ruling is not that the city must keep the documents secret, only that it may. And it shouldn’t. Cowering behind these laws just leaves Pittsburgh residents wondering: What are they hiding?