It’s old news that America’s health insurance system functions poorly; predatory bills, insufficient care and spiraling patient debt are staples of the system. But in the rural counties surrounding Pittsburgh, the real-time breakdown of independent hospitals should move officials to take a closer look at hospital consolidation.

Consolidations, including the ones that created Allegheny Health Network and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center were once heralded as a new dawn in healthcare efficiency and quality. Patients would be able to find specialized care under the umbrella of one organization hosting numerous medical services and providers.

However, a Harvard study from this year found that monopolized hospital systems offer prices that are actually 31% higher than those found at independent health systems.

Odds stacked against them

Advertise with us

Independent, rural hospitals have the odds stacked against them. They have fixed overhead costs for providing vital care that often can’t be offset with their smaller patient pools and an insurance system that works unfairly.

They treat patients that are often older, sicker and on Medicare, which is the most resistant to price increases, and ultimately reimburses hospitals at about half the rate of private insurance. Private insurance itself has been shown to reimburse smaller hospitals less robustly because of their weaker negotiating power.

Conglomerates have size on their side. By representing tens of thousands of patients, they have leverage over insurance companies and can negotiate for higher payouts. The profits, predictably, aren’t being passed on to consumers. Over two dozen people in the c-suite at UPMC and AHN make over a million dollars a year.

According to the Pittsburgh-based Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform, re-evaluating how rural hospitals calculate what they bill insurance can help address their issues. In the traditional fee-for-service system, clinicians are paid based on the number of services provided without considering patient outcomes.

In contrast, in a “value-based payment system,” payments could be adjusted to account for preventative, high-quality and efficient care, not just the quantity. This is a boon for rural hospitals which generally offer care to fewer, older patients with more complex issues.

Advertise with us

Large healthcare systems are also bringing competition directly to struggling rural communities, buying up or opening new practices in remote areas at breakneck speed over the last decade. Over the last decade, AHN and UPMC have saturated the market in Westmoreland and Butler counties with their deeper pockets and higher profit margins.

This “surround-and-drown” strategy has been massively effective at hedging out competition, and studies prove it. Unprofitable rural hospitals are much more likely to close when other hospitals move in.

But simply asking large healthcare providers to put on the brakes on expansion isn’t viable, either. They are economic powerhouses and the biggest employers in the Pittsburgh region, with marketing muscle to match. While their contributions to the city of Pittsburgh and Allegheny County should be acknowledged, their increasing power in the surrounding rural communities should be scrutinized.

Time to reassess

It’s the perfect time to reassess. Right now, UPMC is actively trying to acquire the Washington Health System, another huge rural provider, a process the Federal Trade Commission generally reviews. This is the time for appropriate oversight, as well as a rethinking of a rural hospital funding formula.

The current state of affairs hurts our society’s poor and disenfranchised people most of all. They deserve high-quality and affordable care within their communities. It’s time for government officials to rein in conglomerates and reimburse rural hospitals fairly for the care they provide.