Pittsburgh City Council, in an effort to address a mounting homelessness problem, recently introduced a bill to permit city-sanctioned tent encampments. The measure would create special zoning for encampments managed by the city, a legal space for the unhoused to set up their tents complete with shelter, heat and other necessities.
It’s a humane move that could help the unsheltered homeless someday, but it’s not a permanent answer for those who need shelter now.
High stakes, few solutions
The stakes are high. Limited shelter space coupled with the winter’s wet and cold conditions mean that many unhoused people will be forced to stay outdoors in hostile conditions. Since the closing of Smithfield Street Shelter in June, about 80 people have disappeared from the shelter tracking system, according to the county’s dashboard. They are likely out on the street.
The causes of homelessness spiking for the last half decade are myriad. They include the fallout of a global pandemic, the opioid crisis, a mental health system that simply can’t meet demand and a shortage of affordable housing — including the temporary housing shelters provide. These complex problems have led to encampments springing up around Downtown, the North Shore and the South Side, building a highly-visible public policy failure.
Friction is inevitable when a large group of people are forced to use public space as their living space. While the community discussion about homelessness in Pittsburgh and Allegheny County has been robust, real solutions remain elusive.
Read More
The county has offered no clear leadership on this issue, while the city’s plans have been piecemeal and sometimes contradictory. A new policy to remove encampments that pose a risk to the public has gone largely unenforced because there is nowhere to house the people who would be removed. The city’s other proactive support program, dubbed Reaching Out On The Streets, or ROOTS, previously mishandled its $10-million budget allocation and won’t hire more employees until this January.
A tempting fix
City-supported tent sites are a tempting low-cost fix, especially when compared with solutions dependent on long-term infrastructure improvements, like flipping office space or building more affordable housing.
Most unsheltered homeless people find it easy to transition into this type of encampment, because, much like the “low-barrier” Second Avenue Commons, these outdoor sites allow people to stay with their partners, pets and most belongings — the three things usually deterring unhoused people from staying at traditional shelters.
Being homeless is also stressful, uncertain, and dangerous. Having a stable legal shelter, no matter what kind, can be a crucial first step to more permanent housing.
However, a properly-sanctioned encampment — one that isn’t simply a fenced gathering place for poor people — requires a solid investment from the city. To be fully humane, each encampment will require accessible toilets and showers, 24/7 security personnel, electricity for heating and a proper trash disposal system. Pittsburgh’s current budget and outreach staff can’t handle another intensive program like this without months of planning.
Then there’s the sticky moral aspect. Unfortunately, the mere presence of a legal encampment signals a city endorsement of open-air tent camps for poor residents. That’s a tough stance to defend, especially if there aren’t aggressive and proactive plans in place to find alternatives for people living in them.
It leads to another dicey question: Will these encampments lead to credible offers of housing for the people they serve, or is the city just aiming to move homeless encampments elsewhere to fix the dismal optics? The proposed zoning requirements put forth by city council point to good intentions, but this also adds complexity and a longer implementation process.
New policies
It’s also pertinent to acknowledge how much, and how quickly, policies regarding homelessness have changed. Previous programs and their failings have contributed to a segment of homeless individuals who have, fairly or unfairly, decided that complying with free programs is no longer worth it. Housing in any form comes with stipulations and a level of stability some people just can’t muster. In these cases, tents might be the best the city can do.
There is still some reason to trust the city with a program like this, despite the recent controversies. The shortfalls in its current programs generally come from lack of scale and budget, rather than indifference. Second Avenue Commons, for example, has been at capacity since opening, but nevertheless brought 59 people into permanent housing and helped 69 people find employment over the last year.
The city’s encampment sweep policy has so far resulted in one cleanup, which was, as observed by a member of the Editorial Board, completed in two days and as compassionately and carefully as possible. Good things are happening, but budgeting hangups and staffing limitations have undercut true progress.
The takeaway
The takeaway regarding managed tent cities is optimistic but pragmatic: Their efficacy at making encampments safer and cleaner is credible, but the necessary infrastructure to ensure success will not be ready for this winter. Funding presents another problem, considering that the city has failed to allocate a bulk of its federal pandemic money (or misplaced it completely, like it did with the ROOTS program). All this is not to mention the lean budget years expected as these federal funds run out.
A safe, humane and compassionate solution for our unhoused neighbors will necessarily be multifaceted and complex. It will take time. Unfortunately, those currently living on the streets don’t have that.
Sanctioned encampments are not a final or complete answer to the problem, but the city is right to add this zoning method to the its repertoire of programming. It’s the best that can be done right now.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.