Mitigating homelessness in Pittsburgh will require a coordinated effort between the city and Allegheny County, both of which must also guide private social service organizations to work under them as partners, not competitors. That’s the lesson from cities that have aggressively, and successfully, addressed homelessness — but it hasn’t yet been learned in Western Pennsylvania.
Going into winter, the City of Pittsburgh is sending mixed messages about its policies while the county, which has primary responsibility for social services, says it will announce cold weather plans only in the next couple weeks. Disjointed efforts — including bureaucratic buck-passing and turf-protecting — will never result in a satisfactory response to a growing crisis.
Credible offer
This reality was highlighted last week in remarks by Mayor Ed Gainey’s communications director, Maria Montaño, regarding the city’s policy for removing homeless encampments that impinge on public rights of way. Ms. Montaño indicated that, despite codifying a detailed tent clearance policy last month, the city had no intention to enforce it unless unhoused people have a “credible offer of housing.”
The principle here is sound: that removing people with no other place to go only shuffles the problem around without solving anything. But if the city intended to make its policy contingent on a third-party “credible offer,” it should have included that in the policy. Instead, the city wrote a rule in order to appease stakeholders concerned about settlements overtaking public spaces — apparently with no intent to actually enforce it.
In this context, “credible offer of housing” is a cop out. In social services, “credible offer” is a term of art that refers to several months of guaranteed affordable shelter with all “necessary support” to access and thrive in that accommodation, according to a model policy from the City of London, U.K.
But the entity responsible for arranging such an offer, Allegheny County, is not in a position to do so, and the city knows it. Further, the city has never communicated its newfound “credible offer” policy to the county. City officials seem to think they can have it both ways: appeasing concerned citizens by releasing a tent clearance policy, then blaming others for not enforcing it.
If Pittsburgh ever wants to have a consistent “credible offer of housing” for the region’s unhoused, it will only come through intense city-county collaboration, not grandstanding.
A national problem
Pittsburgh is not the only city struggling to care for its unhoused neighbors. Nationwide unsheltered homelessness increased sharply during the COVID pandemic, followed by the end of programs to support struggling renters. Further, the ongoing opioid crisis and increasing deaths of despair mean that those who have fallen through the social support system are often treading water with temporary solutions.
In Denver, one of the hardest-hit cities in terms of unsheltered homelessness, tent encampments are being addressed aggressively by Mayor Michael Johnston, who took office in 2023 touting his ambitious House1000 Program. The campaign aims to move entire encampments of people into decommissioned hotels, tiny home villages or existing rental units — all with a full suite of social services.
This approach accords with the findings of a 2018 Department of Housing and Urban Development study, which found three primary reasons people stay in encampments: shortcomings in the shelter system, a sense of safety and community and a desire for autonomy and privacy. Allowing people who were living near each other to remain neighbors may be a key to getting them into longer-term housing.
However, unlike federal HUD standards, under Mr. Johnston’s plan, two weeks’ worth of shelter is enough to label someone as “housed.” Plus, some experts wonder whether offering the most intense services to those living in encampments shortchanges people, including vulnerable children and families, already staying in shelters. Despite these drawbacks, the plan should be observed closely by Pittsburgh officials.
Housing first
Meanwhile Houston, a crusader for the Housing First model, has driven down its homeless population by 64% over the last 12 years.
There, success has come through a collaborative effort among the city, county and a consortium of over 100 nonprofits. Under Houston’s current system, nonprofits work as partners, not competitors, and service providers cannot turn down a person deemed to be suitable for their program by the city or county. This required tremendous trust and cooperation.
The main goal of these programs is to offer no-strings-attached permanent housing. Governments have found that taking on this cost is actually much cheaper than the jail-shelter-emergency room orbit many homeless people find themselves in — not to mention much more humane.
Houston has advantages Pittsburgh does not, including famously flexible zoning and newer, denser housing stock. Pittsburgh technically has enough available housing, but much of it is unlivable. This is a challenge, but also an opportunity to create a trailblazing program to mitigate homelessness and blight all at once — something that would only be possible with close city-county collaboration.
Working together
Rather than relying on the way things have always been done here, city and county officials — together — should be studying the successes (and the struggles) of other urban areas working to address homelessness. At the same time, these officials should be discussing ways Pittsburgh can become a model for other similarly situated cities.
There are creative, if imperfect, solutions available: leasing hotels and motels; declaring an emergency in order to streamline processes; creating a nonprofit consortium (which means working with large organizations currently out of favor in City Hall); fixing up blighted properties for unhoused people; and building on, while learning from, local successes such as Second Avenue Commons.
But this will only work with an all-hands-on-deck attitude, not every-man-for-himself posturing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.