Pittsburgh needs more housing — of all kinds. While housing for middle-class, working-class and poor residents must be a priority, when “affordable housing” becomes the only focus of public officials, it undermines economic growth and, ultimately, the cause of affordability itself.
The factors working against building new housing in Pittsburgh are many and complicated, from a restrictive zoning code to a desire for easy and showy fixes to the particular hostility of the Gainey administration. Altogether, they amount to a policy of making the perfect the enemy of the good; of seeing developers as adversaries rather than partners; and of making “no” the default answer to housing, when it needs to be “yes.”
Bloomfield bust
The rejection of a new mid-rise development in Bloomfield offers a case in point.
The former ShurSave grocery store, surrounded by suburban-style parking in the heart of a dense single-family residential and retail district, is one of the worst land uses in the East End. A plan from O’Hara-based Echo Realty would have replaced the field of asphalt with a 6-story (75-foot) apartment complex with 248 units, along with a Giant Eagle supermarket.
But the plot, at the northern end of the Bloomfield Bridge, is zoned Local Neighborhood Commercial — the same as other main streets, like Carson Street and Brookline Boulevard — which comes with a height limit of 45 feet, or three stories. This is set forth in the “Residential Compatibility Standards” in the city’s zoning code, meant to maintain the character of residential neighborhoods and protect residents from “the adverse impacts sometimes associated with adjacent higher density and multi-unit residential development.”
In a vacuum, this is a reasonable requirement. Property owners should have confidence their neighborhoods won’t be radically altered by market forces.
But the city has also added an “inclusive zoning” requirement, which mandates that large multi-family developments set aside at least 10% of units for residents below 60% area median income for the next 35 years. This is also reasonable in principle. But it decreases developers’ return on investment, meaning they have to build bigger to make projects economically feasible — especially in a season of high inflation of construction costs and high interest rates.
In other words, the two zoning regulations — keeping height “compatible” and providing affordable units — cancel out each other. As a result, Bloomfield will get zero new units, either affordable or market rate. And this keeps housing supply artificially low, in turn keeping prices artificially high — and it keeps 25 families from getting homes where they want or need to live.
Supply and demand
The most politically satisfying way to produce affordable housing is simply to mandate it. It allows politicians to brag to their constituents that they fought for them while holding developers’ feet to the fire. That’s why every major new development in the city, from the arena site in the Lower Hill District to Bakery Square in Larimer, devolves into bickering about how much affordable housing will be reserved, at what rates, for how long.
But it’s not at all clear this is the most effective way to create more housing and lower housing prices. The mandates delay and sometimes cancel projects entirely, while also placing them in conflict with other regulations, as in Bloomfield.
The implicit argument from those who favor such mandates, and cheer the cancelation of projects that fail to meet them, is that it’s better to build nothing at all than to build market-rate — that is, in practice, upmarket — residential units. This may be emotionally and even politically satisfying (in the short term), but it’s economically senseless.
Studies consistently show what Economics 101 teaches: Increasing supply decreases prices, even in housing. Even building high-end residential units applies downward pressure on prices by satisfying a demand that would otherwise be met through other means, including speculation in and gentrification of currently affordable neighborhoods.
This is not a quick fix that fits on a campaign flyer, but over the long term in a dynamic marketplace, building more housing helps keep housing affordable.
Mature development
This is why the current, deeply adversarial relationship between City Hall and property developers is both nonsensical and destructive. In an extraordinary statement regarding developer Walnut Capital’s expansion of Bakery Square, Mr. Gainey told the website PublicSource, “If you want something from me you should understand that I’m going to want something in return.”
While there’s nothing new about mayors striking deals with developers, this kind of bald demand for a quid pro quo is unnecessarily hostile — especially after Walnut struck a landmark Community Benefits Agreement with the Larimer Consensus Group that promises $25 million to support the construction of 100 for-sale homes in the neighborhood. For-sale affordable housing is much more complicated than for-rent, but its long-term benefits in terms of building family wealth and stronger communities are unmatched.
The Bakery Square deal represents a mature, long-term approach to economic development and enhancing housing affordability — one that sees that developers and the communities in which they operate can both benefit, when public authorities help guide them to intelligent solutions. In this regard outgoing City Councilman Rev. Ricky Burgess deserves credit for midwifing the deal Mr. Gainey seems determined to scuttle.
Not every housing development deserves support. Some should be opposed, but only for good reason. For instance, the bid to place a high-rise on the site of the Irish Centre in Squirrel Hill suffered from serious traffic and geographic concerns. But as it stands, a combination of legal and political factors has made Pittsburgh actively hostile to new residential development.
And that doesn’t help anyone, especially those who need affordable housing.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.