A bid to move the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police’s Downtown substation to a more spacious PNC-owned location on Wood Street demonstrates the enduring role of public-private cooperation in making effective city government possible. This is exemplified by the deal struck by Councilman Anthony Coghill and Council President Theresa Kail-Smith to reduce the price of the city’s lease for the substation, saving taxpayer money while enhancing public safety Downtown.

The councilors and PNC’s Vice President for Corporate Real Estate Kevin Wade have agreed to reduce the original $85,000 annual lease by 50%, saving the city over $200,000 over the course of the five-year deal.

“It’s the way public-private partnerships should work,” Mr. Coghill told the Post-Gazette Editorial Board. Ms. Kail-Smith said she was “grateful for the partnership with PNC,” as well as for Mr. Coghill’s and Public Safety Director Lee Schmidt’s efforts to strike the deal.

Unfortunately, a spirit of suspicion and animosity toward the private sector has descended on City Hall under Mayor Ed Gainey, exemplified by treating healthcare giant UPMC as a pariah. While there’s no question all corporations are morally complicated, refusing even to attend ceremonies for new hospitals — such as last week’s unveiling of a new pediatric cardiac care center — is unbelievably petty behavior from the city’s elected leader.

Advertise with us

There is no doubt that Second Avenue Commons, the low-barrier shelter that has saved Allegheny County from an even more dire homelessness crisis, could not have been conceived on Mr. Gainey’s watch. That’s because it involved working with and accepting help from the city’s private-sector behemoths, including UPMC, Highmark Health and PNC.

Public-private cooperation doesn’t require naively believing corporations will put aside self-interest in favor of the public good. The Second Avenue Commons partners all received reputational benefits from their collaboration, and improving quality of life in the urban core helps them recruit and retain employees.

The benefits to PNC of offering a sweetheart deal for the police substation are even more obvious: The bureau’s Downtown nerve center will be located at 439 Wood St., in the heart of the bank’s corporate campus. It will enhance employees’ feeling of safety, and perhaps save PNC money on its own private security.

But it also benefits the city, and the people of Pittsburgh as a whole. The current substation in the Lantern Building at Liberty and Sixth is only about one-third the size of the new one, and offers substandard facilities that are the joke of the bureau. The new space will include room for community meetings and a full command post, while being closer to the center of the Golden Triangle.

It’s a perfect example of the intersection of private and public interests, which should be cultivated — not scorned — by city leaders.