Across Pennsylvania in 2022, at least 65 county jail inmates died in custody, but only about 40 of them were reported to federal and state authorities as required by law. That’s according to a new report from Brittany Hailer and Joshua Vaughn of the Pittsburgh Institute for Nonprofit Journalism, which just unveiled a statewide dashboard tracking deaths in these facilities.

The comprehensive database shows how the problems documented in the Allegheny County Jail — poor care, shoddy recordkeeping and cynical workarounds to avoid embarrassing, and often horrifying, death reports — are present across the Commonwealth. Further, the report highlights inconsistencies across Pennsylvania’s jail system that make it difficult to keep track of institutional failings, and therefore to hold those public facilities accountable.

Jails have mechanisms for weaseling out of responsibility, by, for example, not counting an inmate’s death if the person was “released” to a hospital — after falling ill or being injured in jail, but before death. Autopsy reports have also shown medical examiners often don’t perform full autopsies or use technical, or downright misleading, language that shields the jail from responsibility.

This was the case for the family of Anthony Talotta, the man who died in September 2022 after ACJ failed to treat his severely infected leg. The Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s office indicated he had died of natural causes — specifically heart disease — while the hospital where he died listed septicemia, or blood poisoning from his infection, as the actual cause of death. The medical examiner’s barebones report made the death sound much less suspicious than the hospital records, which revealed the scale of the jail’s neglect.

Advertise with us

Performing this kind of thorough investigation is out of reach for most families. PINJ estimated that the total cost to investigate a death and then pursue a lawsuit, like Mr. Talotta’s family did, could be upwards of $80,000. In other words, the system is designed to keep jail deaths mum, and to stonewall grieving families. It’s yet another example of treating the incarcerated as less than human.

Other government agencies, meanwhile, take extreme care when individuals in their custody are in danger. For instance, if a child in foster care is seriously or fatally injured, the Pennsylvania Department of Human Services is required by law to allocate a panel of at least six experts to review the case. Another separate evaluation is conducted following the first, regardless of the initial panel’s findings. Similar protections must be set up for county jail deaths.

People held at ACJ, the majority of whom have yet to be convicted of a crime, should have more robust protections than a two-page medical examiner’s report that may or may not even be submitted. Incarcerated people are at the mercy of the government to meet their needs, and when the government fails, families and communities deserve answers.

PINJ’s tireless work can save lives and make Pennsylvania’s jails more humane places — if state officials can bring themselves to look closely, and to take action.