In terms of the victorious parties at the top of the Allegheny County ballot, voters delivered a mixed message on Tuesday: progressive Democrat Sara Innamorato will be the next county executive, while self-described “law-and-order Democrat” (turned Republican) Stephen A. Zappala Jr. will continue to serve as district attorney.

But beneath the surface, voters also demonstrated a consistent bias in favor of pragmatic and, yes, moderate leadership. Ms. Innamorato’s two-point victory in a county President Joe Biden won by 20% — combined with the fact Mr. Zappala won more votes than she did — clearly denied her anything resembling a mandate for radical change.

In school board races across the region, including conservative Norwin in Westmoreland County, right-wing Republicans angling to limit access to books challenged by parents fared poorly. And in two deep blue county council districts, nominated Democrats handily beat energetic challenges from independent socialists.

All of this week’s victors — as well as sitting officeholders and party leaders — should learn from this election that ideological stridency is increasingly turning off Pittsburgh-area voters.

Advertise with us

The Innamorato transition

In an early sign of organization and seriousness, Ms. Innamorato has already announced several members of her transition team, including a broad-based “Talent Committee.” While some members hail from the activist organizations that have staffed (and influenced) the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey — including SEIU Healthcare executive vice president Silas Russell, who co-chaired Mr. Gainey’s transition and was the subject of a controversial appointment to the city’s planning commission — others represent significant business and policy expertise.

Chief among them are Talent Committee co-chairs Robert Cherry of Partner4Work, a nuts-and-bolts workforce development organization, and Farnam Jahanian, president of Carnegie Mellon University. We are also pleased to see Carlos Carter of the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh, Lisa Schroeder of the Pittsburgh Foundation and Guillermo Velazquez of the Pittsburgh Hispanic Development Corporation on the committee.

Some holes that we hope to see filled in future announcements include more members with experience in economic development — including the building trades — as well as key county responsibilities such as transit, infrastructure and, above all, human services. At the same time, her appointment of former Bill Peduto deputy chief of staff Grant Gittlen as transition director inspires confidence.

However, Ms. Innamorato's appointment of U.S. Rep. Summer Lee’s former campaign manager Abigail Gardner as communications director is concerning. A strong political partisan, Ms. Gardner has, for example, twice indicated on social media that she viewed with disdain Republican Joe Rockey’s affiliation with the Catholic Church. If Ms. Gardner is entrusted with communicating Ms. Innamorato’s priorities to the diverse population of Allegheny County, who is included in, and who is excluded from, her “county for all”?

Advertise with us

Don’t go, Joe

Meanwhile, the Republican candidate demonstrated beyond a doubt that Allegheny County voters will reward promises of moderate, pragmatic leadership. Reaching nearly 49% in a county that delivered a 25-point victory for Democratic Supreme Court candidate Daniel McCaffery, Joe Rockey showed a legitimate path forward for the Republican Party in metropolitan communities: one that rejects the bombast of Trumpism and the screechiness of the culture wars and embraces generosity, reasonableness and brass-tacks governing.

Mr. Rockey outperformed former president Donald Trump in nearly every precinct in the county, showing that conservative voters don’t need a Trump toady or clone on the ballot. While some ardent Trump supporters may have stayed home, Mr. Rockey more than compensated for them by making enormous gains in communities as diverse as Squirrel Hill, Monroeville, Mt. Lebanon and Leetsdale.

We hope Mr. Rockey, 58, will not go back into retirement after this first experience in politics: That would be a terrible loss for the Republican Party and for the Pittsburgh region. The way to heal the dysfunction in the GOP is to elevate conscientious men and women within the party, not to scorn them for affiliating with it.

While this election was a missed opportunity to elevate such a person to public office, it should not be the end of Mr. Rockey’s political career: He should leverage his successful campaign into a leadership role, formal or informal, in the local party, as a force for pragmatism and moderation. And he should run for office again in the future.

Advertise with us

Zappala’s last ride

In contrast, after defeating former chief public defender Matt Dugan in an electoral rematch, Mr. Zappala should indicate that this will be his last term as district attorney. The 66-year-old prosecutor has served the county for 25 years; it is time to prepare the DA’s office for a succession.

While Mr. Zappala has quietly introduced substantive reforms during his career, there is still a great deal of work to be done, as demonstrated by a recent report that Black people are 5.8 times more likely to be charged with a crime than white people in Allegheny County. This is a structural disparity over which prosecutors only have so much control, but they do have a role to play in building a more equitable criminal justice system.

Mr. Zappala should focus on empowering reform-minded deputies in his office to propose and execute new ideas — including those raised by Mr. Dugan, such as sending assistant district attorneys to preliminary arraignments. The best way to ensure he is not succeeded by a radical prosecutor is to make incremental change, right now, toward a model of safety through justice, rather than pitting safety against justice.

Altogether, the lesson of Tuesday’s election — especially for Ms. Innamorato — is that the people are looking for a steady hand, not a bulldozer. Success, both in governing and at the polls, will depend on learning that lesson well.