Everyone agrees American politics is a shambles. The leading presidential candidates are both, somehow, deeply unpopular. And one of the two major national parties, under the influence of a con man who also happens to be one of those two presidential contenders, has become a ridiculous parody of itself, barely able to select its own standard-bearer in the House of Representatives.

Meanwhile, the local Democratic Party has struggled to control its own destructive and radical impulses, resulting in one of the most toxic political atmospheres in recent memory — including elected officials wishing harm on those they oppose.

Rather than complaining, however, on Tuesday Allegheny County voters have an opportunity to take action. In the race for county executive, Joe Rockey offers an opportunity not only to restore optimism to the Pittsburgh region, but to restore some sanity to our politics — and particularly to the Republican Party — by demonstrating that moderate leadership is possible, and popular.

Western Pennsylvania has a long tradition of producing what might be called “progress Republicans” — popular, non-ideological leaders who don’t hate government, but believe in its power, if used carefully, to improve social and economic outcomes. In Allegheny County, the late Senator John Heinz, the late Governor Dick Thornburgh and the first county executive, Jim Roddey, have offered examples of this kind of leadership. Tom Ridge, born in Allegheny County but raised in Erie, also belongs to this category.

Advertise with us

While he will have to prove himself in office, North Side-raised Mr. Rockey has shown that he is a candidate in the tradition of these figures.

Some would have us believe that this kind of pragmatic leadership is no longer what the people what — that they want bombast and grandiosity rather than quiet competence and steady governance. On Tuesday, the voters of Allegheny County can say: “Not yet.”