A scathing lawsuit filed last week, claiming that a developmentally disabled man at the Allegheny County Jail was left to die of sepsis over the course of 10 painful days, showcases the massive and persistent policy issues at the jail. Failure to vet physicians, inconsistent medical documentation and an improper housing placement allegedly led to Anthony Talotta’s preventable death last year.
The negligence began with the hiring of Dr. Wilson Bernales. If Allegheny Health Network, its staffing agency or the jail itself had done proper due diligence when hiring Dr. Bernales, they would have found the doctor had his medical license suspended, revoked or denied in eight states. Dr. Bernales started working at ACJ in July 2022. It only took two months for his incompetence, or perhaps his malice, to result in Mr. Talotta’s death.
Mr. Talotta presented the jail with a complex medical case demanding frequent care — the type of care he could have only received in the jail’s medical housing unit and with proper medical documentation. He had been diagnosed with intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, anxiety and type 2 diabetes. He also had a severe foot injury involving several fractures, torn ligaments and burns.
However, according to the lawsuit, because of his mental health diagnoses he was only eligible to be placed in the mental health housing unit, despite open cells in the medical unit. His placement there ensured he never had access to the intensive medical care doctors knew he needed.
The jail’s inconsistent medical screenings and recordkeeping also allegedly contributed to Mr. Talotta’s suffering. Even though Mr. Talotta was wearing a tall walking boot when he entered the jail, records indicated that he did not have “impaired mobility from casts, bandages, injury, body deformity.” Other paperwork reflected that Mr. Talotta was suffering from “extreme pain,” describing a leg that was swollen, puss-filled and oozing.
The lawsuit claims that Mr. Talotta received no wound care at all. At every juncture, the tools necessary for Mr. Talotta’s medical care were removed. Antibiotics, a walking boot, crutches, gauze and soap administered by outside caregivers were taken from him under Dr. Bernales’ supervision.
The final time he was seen by a doctor, Mr. Talotta was exhibiting signs of severe sepsis. Dr. Bernales only gave him Benadryl. Another inmate carried him back to his cell, where he was found two hours later foaming at the mouth.
The details of the lawsuit are excruciating, and describe a full-system failure. The most glaring mistake, however, was hiring Dr. Bernales in the first place. Prisons are dehumanizing institutions by their very nature. That means it is particularly important to select employees, especially in caregiving roles, who are committed to upholding the dignity of incarcerated people. Both AHN and ACJ failed miserably in this case.
This case must be required reading for candidates to be the new ACJ warden, who must demonstrate they understand and have a plan to fix the breakdowns that led to the death Anthony Talotta.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.