It’s Groundhog Day at Pittsburgh Public Schools, and the district’s board of directors seems to know it. Questions about how to address a lingering budget deficit, aging infrastructure and dwindling enrollment are surfacing late in the year, again leaving little room for proactive measures.

“We talk about the budget only during the last three months of the year … and then there is no further conversation,” board member Kevin Carter said. “And here we are again … talking exactly about the same topics that we talked about a year ago.”

Eventually, there won’t be another year. This year PPS budgeted to spend $16.4 million more than it brought in. Next year, the expectation is closer to $30 million. At this rate, the district’s reserves will run out in 2025 or 2026.

One step in the right direction is obvious, but will come with political costs that, for many years, board members have been unwilling to pay: closing schools.

Advertise with us

PPS continues operating facilities meant to hold 40,000 students while enrolling fewer than 20,000. The average age of the district’s 54 schools is 89 years, meaning they are expensive to maintain while necessary updates, including ventilation and air conditioning, are beyond reach.

Downsizing demands careful planning, stakeholder consultations and public meetings. This is impossible before the proposed budget is unveiled in November, set for a December vote. But planning for next year must begin right now.

In 2021, the district proposed closing six schools, but the plan was tabled, apparently due to insufficient public input. Since then, enrollment has declined another 4%.

Closing schools is difficult, painful and unpopular. Effective and transparent communication is crucial to alleviate some of the expected difficulties. The board must give special care to ensuring poor and Black families are not disproportionately affected by mergers. Community members will want to voice their concerns, and they deserve public forums to express these issues to school leaders.

But pleasing everyone will not be possible. The job of school director is not to win popularity contests — or re-election, for that matter. It is to make hard decisions for the good of the children of Pittsburgh. Any board member who can’t bear to work toward downsizing is free to resign, and should do so.

Advertise with us

Allowing PPS to collapse into insolvency does not help children, or anyone. The board is already years behind in addressing this crisis, which approaches like a dust storm visible for miles and miles away. Any hesitation will only increase the pain of the final, necessary decision to downsize.

“The only way for this to be an efficient and effective process, is if this conversation happens with the same level of intensity all throughout the year,” Mr. Carter told the board. Just so. And the board has to begin immediately.