A five-year contract with Adelphoi, a Latrobe-based non-profit organization that provides youth social services, is not the ideal outcome for Allegheny County’s two-year-long search for a new approach to juvenile justice. But given the county’s previous inability to maintain a facility to state standards, it may be the best option currently available.
The county’s court system, in collaboration with the numerous county departments — Health, Human Services, Corrections and so on — whose work affects at-risk children, should use these five years to develop a modern county-run juvenile justice and rehabilitation system. Private management of this public responsibility cannot be permanent.
At the same time, bickering and grandstanding among county officials about the future of the Shuman Center juvenile detention facility serves no one but politicians looking for attention. It certainly doesn’t serve the struggling young people who need compassionate and evidence-based care and discipline in Allegheny County.
Outrage over action
From the moment Court of Common Pleas President Judge Kim Berkeley Clark and County Executive Rich Fitzgerald announced the agreement with Adelphoi, County Council President Pat Catena and At-large Councilwoman Bethany Hallam have attempted to make the deal a cause célèbre.
Mr. Catena’s initial statement accused his fellow officials of colluding to “warehouse kids in a center run by a for-profit business.” But Adelphoi is a nonprofit organization: Either Mr. Catena was woefully misinformed about an issue he claims to be deeply passionate about, or he knowingly lied to generate outrage.
Mr. Catena also complained that Council was blindsided by the decision to contract with Adelphoi minutes before the public announcement. This was also untrue. Multiple sources confirm to the Post-Gazette Editorial Board that in late August, officials from the courts and the executive branch briefed Council on the plans, including site renderings and the decision to contract with a private agency.
Further, Friday’s announcement that Mr. Catena and Ms. Hallam are planning to seek a court judgment against Mr. Fitzgerald, on the argument the Adelphoi deal oversteps his authority, has all the markings of bad-faith grandstanding. First, both councilmembers know full well that Adelphoi will provide services for the county courts, not the executive branch, and thus the contract is with the judiciary.
Second, both councilmembers have had months — even years — to raise the concern that the other two branches of county government lack the authority to determine the future of Shuman on their own, and to seek legal guidance on the matter. Waiting until now serves only to delay the process of reopening Shuman, which has already been delayed for too long.
A needed facility
In the two years since the 1974-built Shuman facility was closed by the state Department of Human Services for numerous violations of state regulations, Pittsburgh has seen an unusual degree of gun violence among youths — including the February shooting in Carrick of a 17-year-old by a 14-year-old boy on juvenile probation.
Besides the street violence that might have been avoided if a local facility were available, the interim arrangement — which has involved sending young people adjudicated delinquent to Adelphoi’s Westmoreland County facility or even to Jefferson County, Ohio — has strained families and served both detainees and their communities poorly.
Allegheny County needs a local juvenile facility for short-term detention of young people who need time to cool off in a secure environment, and for whom other options are inadequate. (When Shuman closed in September 2021, the average stay for a detainee was 12 days.) Without Shuman, some young offenders have been released to families who love their child but who recognize their inadequacy to deal with the child’s troubles. It is easy to say that no young person should ever be securely detained, but this simply doesn’t reflect reality.
Of course no serious person believes any longer that incarceration is the answer for at-risk young people and childhood trauma. The new Shuman must be fully integrated into the county’s suite of social services, including the offices of Behavioral Health (OBH) and Children, Youth and Families (CYF) within the Department of Human Services. Detention should be a time during which all parties, including the courts, collaborate to design a personalized re-entry plan for the detainee.
A temporary solution
Adelphoi’s record is not spotless. There have been allegations of misconduct and mismanagement at Adelphoi facilities, and a law firm is seeking clients for suits regarding abuse it claims the organization covered up. It goes without saying that the county must establish strict oversight of Adelphoi’s management of Shuman. To this end, the county wisely included an out-clause in its contract with the provider.
While even nonprofit service providers can have perverse financial incentives to minimize costs and maximize revenues at the expense of clients, it should be said that the contract does not scale Adelphoi’s compensation to the number of clients it receives. In other words, despite Mr. Catena’s alarmism, there won’t be a profit motive to detain children at the facility, which will open with 12 beds with a plan to make 60 available.
Still, the county courts should consider this five-year deal not a trial run but a temporary stopgap. Officials should study best practices elsewhere, and lobby state government for less restrictive regulations for juvenile justice that would allow for innovation and compassionate experimentation. We previously advocated for a committee of experts and practitioners, as well as adults who had been detained as children, which should be convened in the coming years to plan for a post-Adelphoi future.
But the fact that private management of Shuman is not ideal doesn’t mean there was a better option on the table right now. Legal and political grandstanding will only further delay the renewal of an essential social service.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.