Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen Zappala’s “video briefing” on a notorious May 2022 Downtown shooting, released last week, purported to be an example of his office’s commitment to transparency with the public. In reality, however, the video sensationalized crime while violating the American Bar Association’s code of prosecutorial ethics — potentially threatening the office’s pursuit of justice for victims of violent crime.
Further, Mr. Zappala’s newfound commitment to “transparency” raises questions about other cases about which he remains mum, such as the pending charges against the Pittsburgh Police officers involved in the Bloomfield tasing, and later death, of Jim Rogers in fall 2021.
Mr. Zappala’s video recounts the events of May 29, 2022, when Marquez Anger and Londell Falconer Jr. participated in a drive-by shooting near the corner of Fourth Avenue and Stanwix Street. The two young men strafed a parked car containing their targets — Hezekiah Nixon and Tylajae Johnson, according to Mr. Zappala — but the bullets missed the adults while striking 18-month-old De’Avry Thomas in the back seat. Anger and Falconer were convicted of first-degree murder on June 7 of this year.
The details about the murder and investigation provided by Mr. Zappala are interesting, though their value to the public at this point is not clear, besides satisfying morbid curiosity. The district attorney went much farther, however, when he described the intended targets of the shooting as “criminals.”
These “criminals” — Mr. Nixon and Ms. Johnson — have since been indicted in association with other gun violence on the North Side. But their cases are still pending, which means they are legally innocent. Referring to them as “criminals” clearly violates the ABA code of ethics, which states, “The prosecutor should not make … a public statement that … will have a substantial likelihood of materially prejudicing a criminal proceeding or heightening public condemnation of the accused.” In violating this rule, Mr. Zappala risks his ability to do his job as DA, by giving defense attorneys reason to argue that he has tainted the jury pool.
This is ironic, because one purpose of the video is clearly to establish Mr. Zappala’s “law and order” bona fides as he runs on the Republican ticket this November against progressive Matt Dugan, who defeated the incumbent in the Democratic primary. Disparaging references in the video to more left-wing officials, including the administration of Mayor Ed Gainey, city councilman Bobby Wilson and state Rep. Emily Kinkead, point toward this political interpretation — and give the impression of using public resources for political purposes.
Meanwhile, Mr. Zappala has yet to disclose the results of a grand jury empaneled to examine police officers’ conduct in the Jim Rogers case. Last October he told the public he would “have something soon.” That was ten months ago. If these “video briefings” are about law enforcement, and not just reelection, the next one should be about the Rogers case.
The prudence that comes with being a veteran prosecutor should be one of Mr. Zappala’s biggest selling points in the coming election. Stunts like this one throw that strength into doubt.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.