The hardest job in the United States right now doesn’t belong to President Joe Biden or tech mogul Elon Musk, but to Attorney General Merrick Garland, who has helmed the Justice Department during two of the most politically sensitive prosecutions in U.S. history: Donald Trump and Hunter Biden. In the case of President Joe Biden’s son, Mr. Garland made the right call in appointing U.S. Attorney for Delaware David Weiss as a special counsel.

The special counsel designation makes Mr. Weiss the final authority in the matter of Hunter Biden. This minimizes the appearance of a conflict of interest in President Biden’s DOJ investigating, bringing charges against and negotiating with the president’s son — especially because some aspects of the case could implicate the president himself.

As we have said in every instance, from Supreme Court ethics to Mr. Trump’s misdeeds, the appearance of integrity is essential to public trust. Relinquishing authority to Mr. Weiss will make the result of the Hunter Biden case, whatever it might be, as broadly acceptable to the people as possible.

This is especially important after the initial plea deal offered to Mr. Biden collapsed under the perceptive questioning of federal Judge Maryellen Noreika. The deal would have resolved some drug and firearm charges against Mr. Biden by placing him in a prison diversion program, which is not unusual for similar first-time offenders. What was unusual was that it made the presiding judge the final authority over whether Mr. Biden complied with the agreement, an unprecedented and possibly unconstitutional arrangement that could have threatened the deal’s enforceability.

Advertise with us

More concerning, the diversion agreement seemed to immunize Mr. Biden from prosecution on much more serious allegations, specifically that he violated the Foreign Agents Registration Act (FARA) by failing to disclose his work on behalf of Ukrainian and Chinese firms to whom he sold his proximity to his father, then the vice president. Whether the elder Mr. Biden was aware of, or profited from, these activities is the subject of an ongoing GOP-led inquiry by the House Committee on Oversight and Accountability.

In a remarkable episode of live courtroom drama, lawyers for Mr. Biden and the DOJ found they disagreed on this fundamental point of the deal, with the prosecutors saying that FARA investigations were ongoing. Unable to renegotiate the deal on the spot, it collapsed. The confusion, and the peculiar nature of the proposed deal, only heightened suspicion that Mr. Biden might be getting special treatment.

Giving Mr. Weiss the broad and independent authority of a special counsel won’t eliminate mistrust of the justice system, but it will make it less reasonable. If it were not for the legal jeopardy faced by Mr. Trump — including a new set of explosive charges in Georgia this week — this would be the most politically sensitive, and sensational, legal drama in recent years. Thus far, Mr. Garland deserves praise for steering the Department of Justice through some of the most treacherous waters it has ever navigated.