The Sept. 29 retirement of long-time Allegheny County Jail warden Orlando Harper provides an opportunity for a hard reset at a facility that has become a focal point for outrage and activism. There’s no reason to wait to start the process of filling this crucially important vacancy.
The hiring of a new warden, along with the election of a new county executive, is also an opportunity for a reset of the relationships among the jail, the Jail Oversight Board and the executive’s office. While the energetic work of the oversight board has brought problems at ACJ to light, a National Commission on Correctional Health Care report on the jail found last year that the animosity between the board and jail leadership, generated especially by at-large county councilor Bethany Hallam, has hampered practical reforms.
Unfortunately, though unsurprisingly, the process to replace Mr. Harper has begun on an immediately contentious note, with Ms. Hallam calling on County Executive Rich Fitzgerald not to take any action — even engaging a search firm — until his successor has been inaugurated. That would introduce an unnecessary delay of nearly five months — something both county executive candidates, Democrat Sara Innamorato and Republican Joe Rockey, have sensibly rejected.
Both Ms. Innamorato and Mr. Rockey have rightly insisted that the next executive should select the next warden, and Mr. Fitzgerald agrees. After all, the last warden search lasted nearly two years: It would be all but impossible for Mr. Fitzgerald to rush his own candidate through, even if he wanted to.
A dozen years ago, previous executive Dan Onorato began the warden search process and Mr. Fitzgerald saw it through. That should be the model this time: A consultant can collect candidates, conduct preliminary interviews and gather community input independent of Mr. Fitzgerald, and present its findings to his successor.
For her part, Ms. Innamorato is right that the process must include a robust community engagement process, including “family of incarcerated people, formerly incarcerated people, [and] workers at the jail.” Mr. Fitzgerald should be certain to select a search firm ready to build such a community committee, or to do so himself.
Ms. Hallam has also indicated she and other reform advocates have a list of possible wardens, which they should share with the search firm.
Mr. Harper’s tenue at ACJ was mixed. He can rightly be proud of enhanced suicide prevention measure and re-entry programs. But the jail’s overall safety record was dismal — a fact highlighted all the more by his careless (at best) fudging of jail death rates. In a reflection of his declining connection with the community the jail serves, this board called for his ouster last year.
The next warden should be ready to run a more transparent facility, more open to reform, oversight and criticism than Mr. Harper’s has been. The county executive chooses the warden, but the oversight board must confirm the choice. After its contentious relation with Mr. Harper, we expect the oversight board to give the new warden its support in correcting what the warden did badly and building on what he did well.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.