The proposed merger of the Washington Health System into UPMC raises a troubling question: How would the consolidation affect maternity care in southwestern Pennsylvania? The Downtown-based health giant must commit to keeping Washington Hospital’s labor and delivery unit open. The convenience and safety of mothers south of Allegheny County depend on it. Without that unit, they will lose the last maternity ward until the state line.
Research consistently shows that hospital consolidation drives up costs, with no increase in quality-of-care. Mergers continue, however, because community hospitals and small health systems, given the economic of the U.S. health care system, struggle to survive. Often, takeovers are the least undesirable option for rural and smaller communities.
Consolidation enables large systems to save money by centralizing services, and maternity care has been a major player in that process. Smaller hospitals in regions with declining populations — that is, fewer babies — struggle to keep their maternity wards profitable. So they either close or merge into a single location. As a result, women sometimes must travel dozens of miles for regular prenatal care — and spend over an hour in the car, while in labor, to reach the delivery room.

These worrisome trends are reflected in Pennsylvania’s 2020 birth data, the most recent available. Hospitals with maternity wards report between a few hundred and several thousand babies a year: Magee-Women’s Hospital tops the list with nearly 10,000, almost twice as many as the second-biggest unit. But some hospitals report single-digit births, which represent emergency-room deliveries for mothers who don’t make it to their planned hospital.
Such deliveries typically amount to one or two — except in Fayette County, where the Uniontown Hospital reported nine emergency deliveries in 2020. Highlands Hospital in Connellsville added two more. Why so many emergency room births in Fayette County? There are no maternity wards for dozens of miles in each direction.
That is not only inconvenient for mothers but also less safe. Emergency rooms are not as well-equipped as maternity wards to handle births, or any attendant complications.
In fact, there are no maternity wards in any county on Pennsylvania’s southern border until the Chambersburg Hospital in Franklin County, more than halfway to Delaware. That’s why so many Pennsylvania moms deliver in Morgantown or Wheeling, W.Va., or Cumberland, Md.
If UPMC were to close the Washington Hospital’s labor and delivery unit in favor of Magee’s industrial-scale birthing operation, a county of more than 200,000 people — and growing — would lose its only maternity ward, and many people in Greene and Fayette counties would lose their closest facility. It would leave St. Clair Hospital (Mt. Lebanon) and the new unit at Jefferson Hospital (Jefferson Hills), as well as Westmoreland Hospital (Greensburg), as the only delivery facilities south of Pittsburgh until the state line.
As community members, as well as state and federal regulators, prepare to scrutinize the Washington Hospital deal, UPMC must reassure them that, in the critical area of maternity care, it will not abandon Washington County.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.