Today, 12 ordinary people provided a measure of justice for their 11 Jewish neighbors who were murdered on October 27, 2018. Joyce Fienberg, Richard Gottfried, Rose Mallinger, Jerry Rabinowitz, Cecil and David Rosenthal, Bernice and Sylvan Simon, Daniel Stein, Melvin Wax, Irving Younger were killed as they worshipped.
In finding Robert Bowers guilty on all counts, including 22 federal hate crimes charges, the jurors rightly rejected a desperate argument by his attorneys that his actions were motivated primarily by a deluded fear of refugees, not a deep-seated antisemitism.
The truth, of course, is that it was both. The shooter had entered into an increasingly mainstream abyss of hatred and panic and conspiracy, where good and evil are reversed. It was precisely the Jewish values of care and compassion for the oppressed and the outsider, personified by the joyful worshippers at the Squirrel Hill synagogue, that drove him to commit the worst act of antisemitic terror in American history.
It makes no sense, but it did to him. Hate turns everything upside-down and inside-out, including truth and reason themselves. And every person who participated in the online conversations that warped the shooter’s mind and soul bears responsibility.
The past three weeks of testimony have made known the full measure of the horror of that fall day five years ago. Victims and first responders described the transformation of a house of worship into a charnel house.
Among the most disturbing but heroic testimony was that of 911 dispatcher Shannon Basa-Sabol, who listened as her caller, Bernice Simon, was shot and killed. And then there was the eerie testimony of Officer Justin LaPaglia, who swept into the synagogue while the shooter was still inside. What he remembered was only silence, with the exception of rifle shell casings rolling across a marble floor — the sound of the infiltration of violence and death into a place of peace and life.
The penalty phase of the trial is expected to begin on Monday, June 26, and may last up to six weeks. The shooter’s attorneys will undertake the honorable task of trying to preserve him from the death penalty, which will be more difficult after the hate crimes convictions. The testimony will include many victim statements that will attest to the permanent void the shooter opened in the lives of families and the community.
No earthly justice can compensate for the violent deaths of 11 innocent people, and the physical and psychological trauma inflicted on so many others. Fair trials and just verdicts are the best we can do. They are part of how we care for one another and for the community we share.
And continuing to care for one another every day, including especially the oppressed and the outsider, is the best antidote to the poison of hate.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.