State funding of county-based 911 services is falling behind costs, leaving counties to pick up the slack with property tax revenue they need for other services. The state legislature should approve Gov. Josh Shapiro’s plan to increase the flat 911 surcharge on phone bills, while cutting duplicative cellphone taxes. The result will be savings for cellphone customers and a solidified state 911 system.

The Pennsylvania Emergency Management Agency (PEMA) administers funds to the state’s 67 counties, but the amount it receives from the 911 surcharge of $1.65 per month per phone isn’t keeping up with the cost of the system. In 2021, the last year for which data is available, the fee covered only 74% of the nearly $442 million cost to provide the service, leaving over $115 million for counties to pick up. That’s worse than 2020, when the fee covered 77% of costs.

As a result, some call centers are seeing over vacancy rates of up to 20%, meaning that shifts are being dropped and existing dispatchers have to work more hours, increasing the chances for mistakes and — just as serious — burnout. Their jobs expose them to tremendous stress, and they suffer rates of post-traumatic stress disorder double or triple the general population’s.

Worse, unless reauthorized, the 911 cellphone surcharge will sunset at the end of this year. The County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania (CCAP) is asking for a more significant increase in the surcharge than Mr. Shapiro: an immediate $0.65 bump to $2.30, followed by $0.15 every year for five years, up to $3.05, until the fee needs to be reauthorized once again. Mr. Shapiro is proposing a one-time increase to $2.03, followed by increases pegged to inflation. The difference between the two options is less than $40 per cellphone over the next five years.

Advertise with us

But that $40 would mean a much safer system. Given the low cost to consumers, and the enormous benefit of the funding for public safety, the legislature should approve a heftier increase.

Meanwhile, whichever way the 911 surcharge goes, it will likely be offset by the end of Pennsylvania’s duplicative cellphone taxes — a smart Shapiro proposal already moved by the state House. Pennsylvania is one of only six states to tax cellphone plans twice: a 6% sales and use tax plus a 5% gross receipts tax on the providers, which is of course passed along to the consumer. The income goes into the general fund.

The House proposal would nix both of those. The Senate should amend the bill to kill the gross receipts tax but keep the easier to administer sales tax. Either way, for consumers, the savings will offset the 911 fee boost, at a small decrease in income to the general fund.

A small rearranging of the way Harrisburg treats phone plans can enhance 911 funding while saving consumers a few bucks. It’s good public policy, and a good way to use the state’s unusually full coffers.