As the Democratic nominee for Allegheny County Executive, state Rep. Sara Innamorato, 37, of Lawrenceville, faces many of the same kind of questions Ed Gainey faced when he sought the Pittsburgh mayor’s office.
How will a back-bench state legislator only in her third term transition to the role of chief executive of a major government? Will someone whose primary management experience is heading a small legislative staff be able to lead and to wield a multi-thousand-person bureaucracy? How will a figure propelled to office by the progressive wing of the Democratic Party, and supported primarily by a single special interest in the SEIU, serve as a leader for all her diverse constituents?
Nearly a year and a half into his term, Mr. Gainey provides a cautionary tale for Ms. Innamorato: Running a government is hard, and it’s all the more difficult when ideological purity, rather than administrative competence, is a campaign’s driving principle. We had high hopes that Mr. Gainey would focus on consensus-seeking and brass-tacks governing, which would have been the more effective way to achieve lasting progressive reforms. Instead, the administration has focused on undermining its predecessor’s initiatives — many of which aligned with progressive ideals — while advancing few of its own.
Indeed, the Gainey administration’s struggles to fulfill basic duties, from filling boards and committees to calling police academy classes to maintaining a wildly popular literacy program, show that political ideals don’t matter without the competence to see them through.
Meanwhile, after receiving $350,000 in campaign contributions from the SEIU, Mr. Gainey appointed several union employees to key roles in city government. City Council has referred his appointment of SEIU Pennsylvania political director Silas Russell to the city’s Planning Commission to the state Ethics Commission. The union has been in a years-long battle to organize health care workers at UPMC, a goal which has driven the administration’s counterproductively contentious relationship with the region’s largest employer.
The SEIU has also contributed at least $280,000 to Ms. Innamorato’s campaign — and the Working Families Party, which is funded in part by the SEIU, purchased $400,000 of television ads in support of her candidacy. Only in the coming days, as last-minute contributions from SEIU front groups are tabulated, will it be possible to discern exactly how much the union invested in her.
It will be up to Ms. Innamorato to convince voters, between now and November 7, that she will prioritize governing this county of 1.25 million people, as opposed to progressive gestures, score-settling and advancing the agenda of the SEIU.
Tuesday’s election did not select the next county executive, but only the candidates who will face off in the general election. While the Democrat will enter the race as the heavy favorite, Republican Joe Rockey, a former executive at PNC, could prove a formidable opponent — especially if Ms. Innamorato struggles to distinguish her plans for Allegheny County from Mr. Gainey’s governance in Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.