Nearly 19 months ago, Jim Rogers, a Black man who lived mostly in shelters, died after Pittsburgh Police officers Tased him repeatedly on a residential street in Bloomfield. Last week, an attorney for Mr. Rogers’ family confirmed an $8-million settlement in the federal wrongful-death lawsuit against the City of Pittsburgh, its police department and its paramedics.
Pittsburgh Police should learn many lessons from this tragedy, including this one: Bad policing, like poor in-custody practices in jails and prison, is not only ineffective and inhumane, but also extremely expensive. Every taxpayer pays for this negligence and malpractice.
An incident like Mr. Rogers’ death also erodes community trust and police legitimacy. The damage to police/community relations caused by this fatality endures, even as a new Pittsburgh Police Chief, Larry Scirotto, takes command.
Nothing Pittsburgh Police can do will make this right. But the department and city can take steps to show they are committed to doing better. Attorney Todd Hollis has asked police to enact more than 30 policing reforms, including guidelines for using force and Tasers, delivering medical care, creating a public database for use-of-force incidents and training on de-escalation. Pittsburgh Police should carefully consider each recommendation, as well as renew a commitment to a culture of respect.
Mr. Rogers, 54, died Oct. 14, 2021, a day after his encounter with police officers who were responding to an alleged bicycle theft in Bloomfield. Pittsburgh Police took what should have been the most minor of encounters and escalated it into a death sentence. A lack of training didn’t do that. At bottom, those officers didn’t see Mr. Rogers as a human being.
Throughout this ordeal, Pittsburgh Police have been less than transparent. They declined to name the officers involved, though the department fired five of them and disciplined and retrained three others. The department also withheld an internal report from the District Attorney’s Office.
For more than a year, activists, including Mr. Rogers’ family, have urged District Attorney Stephen Zappala to bring criminal charges against some of the officers. The public deserves to know — now — whether the DA’s office plans to do that.
Unnecessary death
Mr. Rogers’ death was tragic because it was entirely unnecessary, resulting from, as Mr. Hollis said, a “most egregious lack of humanity” by Pittsburgh Police. Excessive force, medical indifference, false arrest, assault, lack of due process and negligent training for officers were among the civil rights violations raised in the lawsuit.
A woman called 911 to report a man had taken a bike from her neighbor’s porch. (Other neighbors said the bike was left outside for anyone to take, and Mr. Rogers took it for a spin.)
An officer questioned Mr. Rogers on Harriet Street, and searched him for weapons. (He had none.)
The officer threw Mr. Rogers to the ground, started yelling at him, and Tased him. More officers arrived a few minutes later.
Officers Tased Mr. Rogers multiple times, witnesses said, even though he was attempting to comply with their orders.
Mr. Rogers pleaded for medical care. Instead, officers drove him to the Allegheny County Jail, and then on to UPMC Mercy, after they noticed Mr. Rogers’ condition getting worse. He died the next day.
Reform department
The Medical Examiner’s Office ruled Mr. Rogers’ death an accident, following an interruption of blood flow to the brain. But, as in so many in-custody deaths, rulings of accidental or natural causes obscure preceding negligence and malpractice. At any rate, such cause-of-death rulings are not moral or legal findings. That’s when lawsuits become the only recourse for victims’ families, as well as a singular source of oversight for police departments, jails and prisons.
A man died without cause at the hands of police officers who were sworn to serve and protect. That should give the Pittsburgh Police Department and its new chief more than enough motivation to reform the department’s practices on use-of-force and public transparency, and cultivate a culture of respect that will de-escalate tensions, instead of turning them into a crisis.
Mayor Ed Gainey can start a new day in Pittsburgh policing by offering Mr. Rogers’ family a formal and unqualified apology. If sincere, an apology is more than an empty gesture. It reflects the humility — a trait law enforcement often lacks — necessary to change the culture of an entire department.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.