Pennsylvania’s closed primary system disenfranchises independents and polarizes the political process. It’s time to scrap this undemocratic system, which prevents political independents from influencing which candidates advance to the general election.
To make Pennsylvania primaries fair and representative, legislators should support a bipartisan bill, sponsored by Sens. Lisa Boscola, D-Northampton, and Dan Laughlin, R-Erie, that would open primary elections to independents. Aside from Pennsylvania, only eight states’ primaries are entirely closed.
Allowing independents — currently about 11% of the state’s registered voters — to cast ballots in primaries won’t radically change the results. Still, it would force candidates to pay attention to a broader and more representative constituency, as they attempt to prevail in all-important primary elections.
As it stands, especially in crowded primaries like the Democratic race for Allegheny County Executive, candidates must compete for only a slice of a single party’s voters in low-turnout primaries. That leads to ridiculously undemocratic results. The next Allegheny County executive, for example, could take office with 50,000 or 60,000 votes in a county of nearly 900,000 voters. In many races, primaries are, in effect, general elections, with opposing parties presenting little or no opposition.
Open primaries will increase voter turnout and ensure a more truly democratic process. That’s why good-government groups support them.
In a tight race, no candidate could afford to ignore independents. Unaffiliated voters would add only 93,000 to the pool of voters in Allegheny County, as of the May 1 voter registration tally, but those, generally more centrist, voters would make it harder for a candidate to appeal only to a fringe of the electorate.
Like all voters, independents should have a voice. Too often, they do not. In the 2020 general election, for instance, only 10 of 25 state Senate races, or 40%, were decided by fewer than 20 points. In the state House, only 44 of 203 races, or 22%, had less than a 20-point margin. In these uncontested general elections — which include all races in the City of Pittsburgh — independents are effectively disenfranchised.
The most common system, with 15 states, is an open system in which voters don’t register with a particular party and can vote — only once, of course — in whichever primary they wish.
The Laughlin-Boscola bill doesn’t go this far; it would make Pennsylvania’s primaries only partially open, joining nine other states that allow independents to help pick party nominees. That plan isn’t a panacea, but it’s a definite step toward more representative and fair elections, as well as a less polarized political process. Legislators ought to approve the change quickly, so that independents can have a real voice in next year’s presidential primary.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.