The unveiling of the next Pittsburgh police chief has turned into a fiasco, underscoring the incompetence of the Gainey Administration, and perhaps the mediocrity of the finalists themselves. Months of recruiting should have yielded a better group of finalists: Two of the three finalists were recently fired by the cities whose police departments they led. Is this the best Pittsburgh can do?
Making matters worse, the administration’s clumsy handling of announcing the new chief has led to confusion and misinformation, a bad way to start the tenure of a police chief whose top job will be improving the department’s trust and credibility in the communities they serve. This is what happens when an agency, or city, operates with a lack of transparency.
Media outlets, including the Post-Gazette, have reported Mr. Gainey has offered the job to Larry Scirotto, a former assistant chief in Pittsburgh who was fired as head of the Fort Lauderdale, Fla, department. But Mr. Gainey has not confirmed that, after missing several self-imposed deadlines for announcing the new chief. On Monday, a spokeswoman for the mayor’s office, again, declined to comment.
Another of the three finalists — Frederick, Md., Chief Jason Lando — said Monday he learned Mr. Scirotto had landed the job in Pittsburgh only by watching the news. No one from the mayor’s office had called Mr. Lando, who spent more than two decades with Pittsburgh Police. Community members in Pittsburgh and Maryland praised Mr. Lando’s work to improve police-community relations.
Earlier rumors suggested that Mr. Gainey had offered the job to another finalist, former Boise Police Chief Ryan Lee, which the mayor denied.
Mr. Lee and Mr. Scirotto were recently fired as police chiefs. Mr. Scirotto was let go for allegedly favoring non-white candidates for promotions. He sued the city, claiming he was wrongfully terminated. Mr. Lee was accused of breaking an officer’s neck during a training exercise. A report from a Boise television station alleged nearly two dozen officers had filed complaints against him before he was asked to resign.
Nearly a year has passed since former Pittsburgh Police Chief Scott Schubert announced he would retire. The next Pittsburgh police chief will have a difficult job, including strengthening police-community relations and coping with a staff shortage the Gainey Administration aggravated by failing to call a police academy class last year.
Two weeks ago, Mr. Gainey said the finalists for the chief’s job were “great candidates,” who were all “above an A.”
Truth be told, a year of recruiting should have yielded a higher-quality group. Now, the administration’s inept introduction of the new chief could make a tough job even more difficult.
Correction: An earlier version of this editorial misstated the racial diversity of the finalists for Pittsburgh Police Chief. Ryan Lee is Asian-American.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.