UPMC is hardly an exemplary corporate citizen. The Post-Gazette Editorial Board has regularly criticized and called on it, as well as other large Pittsburgh non-profits, to contribute more to the community through substantial payments-in-lieu-of-taxes.

But the hatchet job on UPMC done in a report — called the “Fair Share Index” — released this month by Lown Institute, a small think tank outside Boston, is a textbook example of how bad data and sloppy methodology can lead to specious conclusions, bad public policy, and unwarranted criticisms. Further, the presence of City of Pittsburgh Chief Operating and Administrative Officer, Lisa Frank, at the report’s launch event, and of U.S. Rep. Summer Lee touting it in a press release, amplified those errors.

The “Fair Share Index” purports to identify the nation’s least generous non-profit hospitals, but undermines its rankings with crude methodology. There’s more than enough to legitimately criticize in the deeply flawed U.S. health care industry, without resorting to disreputable research and one-sided conclusions. It’s unclear what the city hopes to gain with this reckless report, but skewering facts is not how to get it.

The report’s index claims that UPMC Presbyterian-Shadyside is the worst moocher in America, saving $246 million more in Lown-estimated tax breaks than it provides in Lown-defined “meaningful” community benefits. It concludes this by assigning a value of 5.9% of total expenditures to the organization’s tax exemption, then comparing that figure to a subset of “community benefits” reported on IRS Form 990. For hospital groups like UPMC, which does not report data for individual facilities, Lown pro-rates expenditures and community benefits based on revenue.

Advertise with us

That imprecise methodology should immediately raise eyebrows: The $246 million “fair share deficit” for UPMC Presbyterian-Shadyside is pure guesswork, unworthy of an undergraduate term paper. In truth, consumers of this self-styled authoritative report don’t know what proportion of Lown-defined community benefits or expenditures that particular hospital accounts for. Assigning a precise value to those figures, then shaming the hospital as the worst non-profit in America, is sloppy, even unscrupulous.

The Lown Institute also defines a non-profit hospital’s community benefits narrowly, excluding funds spent on research and health professional training — and even the deficit between sticker price and Medicaid reimbursements. As a result, hospital groups like UPMC, which treats an unusually high proportion of Medicaid recipients, are punished. UPMC also provides a disproportionate amount of the charity care that Lown supposedly does count: The network treats 18% of Pennsylvania inpatients and provides 28% of charity care.

As far as IRS-defined contributions, UPMC’s $1.5 billion, accounting for more than 10% of net patient revenue, places it above average among large health care networks nationwide.

Public officials, or anyone else, should avoid taking self-styled authoritative reports at face value. UPMC is not a model corporate citizen, but the fundamental conclusions of Fair Share Index are inaccurate. In embracing this report, Ms. Frank has done more than damage the hospital’s reputation: she’s undermined her own credibility, and the credibility of the administration she serves.