A 2021 MovePGH initiative to add rental Spin electric scooters throughout the city sounded like a good way to improve public transportation and mobility in Pittsburgh. But two years later, scooters have become a menace that must be stopped.
Frequently driven in an unsafe and even reckless manner, scooters are threatening pedestrians and cluttering up the city. The idea that scooters should be parked in designated spots is widely ignored, and Spin still hasn’t provided a way to report abandoned scooters. Scooters are dropped outside buildings, on front lawns, or even in the streets. Small wonder that, across the pond, the people of Paris, France, recently voted to ban rental electric scooters. Pittsburgh should do the same.
A recent drive from Squirrel Hill to Downtown — across the campuses of Carnegie Mellon, the University of Pittsburgh, and Carlow University — showed scooters weaving in and out of traffic, taking over sidewalks, and forcing pedestrians onto yards or the street. One woman pushing a baby stroller had to shove it off the sidewalk to avoid a collision.
Spin touted their now-ubiquitous orange and black scooters as accessible, affordable and equitable.
Baloney, suggested a report recently released by Pittsburghers for Public Transit. People over 220 pounds, under 18 or physically disabled can’t use them. Scooters can’t traverse a hill. When they are left on sidewalks or streets, they hinder mobility. “As a blind person,” city resident Gabriel McMorland told City Council members this month, “I regularly encounter scooters that block safe passage in my neighborhood sidewalks.”
That’s unacceptable.
Scooters are also expensive, costing users nearly $5 per mile. Even a touted low-income program, which few users qualify for, charges more than $1.50 per mile. The bus is far cheaper; in some cases, even private vehicles cost less.
Last fall, the Post-Gazette Editorial Board supported the program. Dozens of Pittsburgh residents who opposed the scooters at a City Council meeting this month, with convincing and compelling arguments, persuaded the board to reverse its position. The liabilities of the program far outweigh any benefits.
MovePGH had argued that Spin scooters could lower carbon emissions by reducing car trips. But scooters are more likely to replace walking or public transit than personal vehicles, and they have made navigating the city’s narrow roadways and tight spaces more difficult.
Pittsburghers for Public Transit is right. The city should, among other things, focus on improving sidewalks and transit accessibility. Scooters have become more of a nuisance than an asset to public transit and mobility. As the Paris of Appalachia, Pittsburgh should follow that city’s lead and ban them.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.