After one of the worst weeks on the ice in the recent history of the franchise, the Pittsburgh Penguins on Friday scored some big wins that should, in the long run, overshadow missing this year’s playoffs with two humiliating losses.
First, the team fired General Manager Ron Hextall and President of Hockey Operations Brian Burke, clearing the way for a resurgence at the twilight of the careers of Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Kris Letang.
On the same day, the team announced a landmark deal of a different sort: An agreement to restore land and opportunity to the historic Bethel African Methodist Episcopal Church, destroyed in 1957 to to make room for the Civic Arena. The seizure of Bethel AME’s land, and the razing of its grand worship space, was a moral crime against the people of the Hill District. Finally, a belated measure of justice has come.
The deal announced Friday will cede to the church development rights to 1.5 acres of land, with profits accruing to Bethel AME to ensure the long-term financial security of this community institution. Plans remain tentative, but the church envisions a mixed-use development, including up to 350 apartments, some market-rate and others set aside for low-income residents.
The razing of the Civic Arena in 2011 and 2012 provided an opportunity to restore at least some land and financial power to the those injured by “urban renewal.” Instead, as part of the deal that built PPG Paints Arena and kept the hockey franchise in Pittsburgh, the Penguins received full rights to one of the best redevelopment tracts in America: 28 acres of downtown-adjacent real estate.
The Post-Gazette editorial board has been critical of the intolerably slow pace of the Penguins’ development, partly due to complicated negotiations with community organizations about how to balance the demands of business and justice. Even considering these challenges, however, the team has fallen way short.
Friday’s event reflected the greatest unity between the hockey team and the Hill District community — and within the community itself — that Pittsburgh has seen in more than a decade of arguments, negotiations and lawsuits. Every major stakeholder participated, including the Hill Community Development Corporation, which had been particularly skeptical of plans for the tract.
This isn’t the end of the story: Real estate development is tricky, and the project still needs full funding. The church and the community still have plenty to do.
But, finally, control of this historic land’s future is where it belongs: With the community institution that had been this neighborhood’s heart and soul for generations.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.