Last week, members of the University of Pittsburgh Board of Trustees named Joan Gabel, the accomplished president of the University of Minnesota, the school’s first female chancellor. It was an exciting and historic pick that was generally applauded by leaders around the region.
Even so, her compensation package raised a few eyebrows and concerns. Her base salary alone is $950,000. In addition, Ms. Gabel, who starts her job with Pitt in July. will receive five annual $200,000 deferred retention incentive payments, and will be eligible for $100,000 retention payments on the third, fourth and fifth anniversary of her start-date, She also can receive a $5,000 reimbursement for any tax complications arising from her move.
The contract could lay out additional incentives. It isn’t available to the public but ought to be, as Pitt receives taxpayer support.
Ms. Gabel’s compensation package may well be in line with those of her peers, but that’s part of the problem. Over the last five years, salaries for the heads of public universities have become excessive, especially given one of the core mission of public universities: Providing a quality and affordable education. According to U.S. News and World Report, tuition and fees at public research universities, unadjusted for inflation, have risen 141 percent since 2003 for out-of-state students, and 175 percent for in-state students.
Continuing to maintain quality without significant raises in tuition at Pitt will likely take more state funding. Asking for more money from the General Assembly could be a tough sell, given Ms. Gabel’s compensation package. Higher tuitions will be an even tougher sell to college students who must take on tens of thousands of dollars of debt to pay them, or else give up any hope of a college education.
Experts have called Ms. Gabel’s compensation package “the new normal.” Getting the right person for the job required a higher compensation package than the one given her predecessor, Patrick Gallagher, university officials said. Similar arguments have been made for granting far higher compensation packages to top corporate CEOs. But those, too, have come under fire, especially when they are followed by a sub-par or disastrous corporate performance.
But private corporations are just that — private. Salaries for the leaders of public universities, or any non-profit endeavor, should be more restrained. They typically receive taxpayer dollars; they are not required to make a profit, and they engaged in enterprises that are considered, at least to some extent, public service.
None of this is to disparage the outstanding professional qualifications of the new chancellor, or minimize the difficult and significant job ahead of her. Obviously, leading a major university like Pitt requires a large dose of competence, experience, talent and dedication. The decisions she makes will profoundly affect the university and the education it delivers. We know she will do well.
University governing boards, however, must get the salaries of university chancellors and presidents under control — if they don’t want someone else to do it for them.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.