In major cities nationwide, gun violence and homicides are dropping from post-pandemic highs. They are dropping in Pittsburgh and even in Philadelphia. Even so, police statistics for last year, as well as for the first three months of this year, continue to reflect a level of violence that is historically high and unacceptable.

These figures justify neither congratulations nor complacency. Violent crime rates have yet to recover from a 2020 surge associated with the arrival of the Covid-19 pandemic. Now, more than ever, cities need thoughtful and effective community-based strategies that will steadily drive down gun violence over the next decade.

In most cities, homicide and non-fatal shootings rates began to fall last year, from a post-pandemic surge in 2020 and 2021. That didn’t happen in Pittsburgh, where homicides rose 26%, to 71, in 2022.

For the first quarter of this year, however, Pittsburgh reported 16 homicides, down two, or 11%, from the same period last year, and 28% fewer non-fatal shootings. In Philadelphia, which topped 500 homicides in each of the last two years, homicides also dropped — 13% — during the first three months of 2023. Other large cities also have experienced modest drops in violent crime, homicides and non-fatal shootings during the first quarter of 2023.

Advertise with us

Even if those trends continue in Pittsburgh and Philadelphia for the rest of the year, however, violent crime rates in both cities will remain well above pre-pandemic levels.

Philadelphia reported 356 homicides in 2019, the year before the pandemic. Pittsburgh reported 37 — the lowest the city has seen in more than two decades.

To get back to pre-pandemic levels of violence, and then reduce them further, Pittsburgh needs a consistent and coherent strategy that will lower the number of homicides at least into the 20s, strengthen relations between the community and police, and raise homicide clearance rates, which generally have fallen nationwide.

Reducing violence takes a sustained community-wide effort: It takes years of intelligent interventions, creating opportunities for young people, and a permanent change in how the city does business. Efforts to get illegal guns off the streets should also continue.

Mayor Ed Gainey has not provided a consistent message or presence on the issue of violence, and he has ignored initiatives that have worked in other cities, such as using trained ex-offenders as core outreach workers and violence interrupters. After-school programs and sports are excellent preventive measures, and should be more strongly supported, but the city still needs direct intervention with the small number of people who are doing the shooting.

Going to the source of violence to cure or alleviate it takes time, perseverance and hard work. But it’s an effort the people of Pittsburgh will happily undertake, if they know their leaders have an effective plan to stop some of the bleeding.